obviously their Pizza is amazing however everybody sleeps on the rest of the menu... spaghetti and meatballs ftw every single time... also a salad to cancel out the carbs! Roses are red, Violets are blue, NYP has great pizza, And other things tooooooo! 😭🤣🫡
N
Nicolas C
Local Expert • 48 contributions
Loved
• 9/4/25
• DoorDash order
Not cheap, but you're paying for quality. The Stuffed Pizza 18” had perfect crust and so much cheese, and the Cappuccino Fudge Cake tasted super fresh. Ordered the Deep Fried Pizza because I was curious--it's fried and then topped and baked, NOT like a calzone/pocket situation. Will def get it again and try different toppings, this had ricotta and meatball which was great
C
Chris R
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Liked
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich was good, not as good as the meatball sub, chicken was pretty dry. I would definitely recommend going with the meatball sub oic you're getting a sandwich here. Bedt meatball sub in the city! Sandwiches are pretty good portions for the price! While the chicken parm was not bad, everything tasted great but the dry meat, definitely the weakest of the sandwiches i've gotten here
T
Tisha M
9 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/27/24
• DoorDash review
alfredo was bland. for Almost $2 extra you get a half of a mushroom very thinly sliced. the tiramisu is not an actual tiramisu.
S
Stevie M
Local Expert • 40 contributions
Liked
• 3/22/25
• DoorDash order
HUGE Cheese Pizza Pie (18" Large) with pepperoni and extra cheese. Be prepared though, the Spaghetti & Meatballs is just that. Spaghetti & Meatballs . Dont expect any Spaghetti sauce aside from the tiny amount that accidentally ends up on the pasta when they put the Meatballs on. That was a bit disappointing. The Avocado salad and Italian dressing was fantastic. Homemade Poppers were good but for what it is I'm not sure they were $10 good. We will order again but a bit different now that we know what to expect. We will stick with the Pizza and salad. I recommend you give it a try.
