Best Pizza Restaurants Nearby in Shirley
Mama Lisa Restaurant
4.5
(15k+)$0 delivery fee • 0.8 mi • 24 min
15% off on $35+
"Literally everything from mama lisas is the best! I have never had a bad meal here! The chicken Marsala from here is the best one you will ever have. I get my Christmas Eve dinner catered from here too and all my guests love it! "
"I have eaten many times at Mama Lisa and it's good. Tonight I ordered Chicken Cacciatore and it was excellent. It may be the best thing I have ever had from there. Nice size portion, enough for 2 meals or to split. Would 100% order again. "
Pasta alla Vodka
Pink cream vodka sauce with prosciutto, peas and bits of onions. All pasta dinners served with freshly baked bread.
$20.44
Cheese Pizza | Neapolitan (slice)
With tomato sauce.
$3.84
Chicken Cutlet Hero w/ Tomato Sauce
Served with 4 oz. tomato sauce.
$12.42
Soda | 2 Liter
With tomato sauce.
$4.55
Pizza Hut
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 900 ft • 26 min
20% off on $20+
"The Cheese Sticks and my 6" Personal Pan Pizza were amazing!! Hot and not burnt, quick delivery! Highly recommend"
"I ordered a Personal Pan Pizza® and Oven-Baked Chicken Alfredo Pasta which came with 5 bread sticks. Everything was delicious as always. Food was delivered hot. For $20 its a great deal cause I can get 2 more meals out of this, way too much food for one sitting!"
Personal Pan Pizza®
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$7.7
Create Your Own Pizza
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$21.74
Cheese Sticks
A side everyone can agree on! Get these cheese sticks sprinkled with flavorful Italian seasoning and a cup of our delicious marinara.
$8.34
Big Dinner Box
All your faves - 2 medium 1-topping pizzas, 8 boneless wings, and 5 breadsticks!
$29.95
Joe's Original Pizza
4.4
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.3 mi • 32 min
20% off on $20+
"Joe's pizza wow not enough words to describe but amazing best price best food the quality is by far amazing the texture the sauce everything perfection the dough is unbelievable my first pizza I can actually eat the crust I never eat the crust of any pizza Joe's pizzeria is the first ever in all my years"
"The bake ziti is so good and the sauce is excellent and I got more than expected everything was delicious . I highly recommend them."
Regular Extra Large Pizza (Cheese)
Crispy chicken cutlet topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$19.86
Garlic Nots
Served with bread.
$3.67
Regular cheese pie
Lasagna, ravioli, manicotti, and stuffed shells. Served with bread.
$18.18
Mozzarella Sticks half
Served with bread.
$8.53
Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.9 mi • 33 min
"The best Italian food around and it's not even remotely close. Everything here is delicious and fresh. Always quality. Pizza is amazing. Garlic knots are amazing. Chicken parm is fantastic. "
"Nino’s Pizzeria is hands down one of the best spots around! The food is absolutely delicious — from the crispy, perfectly baked pizza to their amazing pasta dishes, everything is full of flavor. You can tell they use quality ingredients and put care into every meal. Highly recommend if you’re craving real Italian comfort food. Great service too!"
Baby Pizza
comes with sauce
$12.72
(6) Garlic Knots
comes with sauce
$5.97
Pepperoni Wheel
In a pink cream sauce with light meat sauce
$5.86
Mozzarella Sticks (8 pcs)
Served with fresh mozzarella tomato and basil.
$15.7
Pizzeria Los Amigos
4.8
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.5 mi • 33 min
Rave Reviews
"THE BEST CALZONE IVE HAD IN A LONG TIME. THEY ARE NEVER COOKED PROPERLY ,THIS WAS SO GOOD. LOS AMIGOS DOES THEM RIGHT ! DOUGH WAS PERFECT. CHICKEN PARM HERO ALSO PERFECT. AND THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF SAUCE. NO DRY SPOTS IN THE HERO ! "
"AMAZING AMOUNT OF QUALITY FOOD FOR THE MONEY. EVERYTHING ON POINT. WELL STUFFED TACOS. FAJITAS WERE REALLY GOOD. ENOUGH FOR 2 PEOPLE. HAD THEM ABOUT A YEAR AGO. THE SAME RESULT, GREAT PLACE."
Large Pizza
18". With mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.
$23.56
Garlic Knots
3 Pieces. Short rib, mozzarella cheese, cilantro, onion and side of ajus.
$3.78
Birria Taco
1 large pie, 20 buffalo wings (choice of sauce) and 12 garlic knots, 1 - 2 liter soda.
$17.02
Regular Pizza Slice
6 pieces. Served with homemade tomato sauce.
$5.32
Domino's
4.5
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 0.8 mi • 48 min
"The new Cinnamon Bread Bites are INSANE !!!! Buttery soft hot and icing game changer and The Pacific Veggie Pizza a win win"
"Once I got there, they had no idea what my order was or that I had even made it and said it probably went somewhere else. Then my name popped up on the screen that said it was already ready. They also forgot part of my order. I ordered 32 cinnamon bites and 32 Parmesan bites and only got 16 of each "
Build Your Own Pizza
A custom pizza made to order. Choose from any of our delicious crust styles, including Handmade Pan.
$15.69
Ultimate Pepperoni
Two layers of pepperoni sandwiched between provolone, Parmesan-Asiago and cheese made with 100% real mozzarella then sprinkled with oregano.
$19.05
Coke®
The authentic cola sensation that is a refreshing part of sharing life's enjoyable moments.
$3.43
Wisconsin 6-Cheese
Feta, provolone, cheddar, Parmesan-Asiago, cheese made with 100% real mozzarella and sprinkled with oregano.
$18.86
Bella Pizzeria
4.7
(40+)$0 delivery fee • 0.4 mi • 28 min
Cheese
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$22.39
Papa Johns Pizza
4.5
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 41 min
"This was a nice surprise. I wasn't extremely hungry and wanted something personal sized to eat for dinner. Wow, this was IT. It was so delicious. Almost like an adult sized pizza roll of some kind. Get it with the garlic dipping sauce, thank me later. & believe me, I know nothing beats real New York pizza, but sometimes it's ok to just want a snack ;)"
"There was only one slice that had any sauce on it. And barely any toppings on whole pie. The buffalo chicken bites were gross and chewy. Took one bite and threw them away."
Cheesesticks
Original fresh dough covered with Special Garlic sauce, topped with mounds of real cheese made from mozzarella, then baked to a cheesy, gooey goodness. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping!
$8.94
Create Your Own Pizza
Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!
$15.86
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni, cheese and pizza sauce on your choice of crust.
$14.83
Cheese Pizza
Cheese and pizza sauce on your choice of crust.
$15.01
Carlo's Pizza of Shirley
4.5
(5k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.6 mi • 33 min
"My favorite things from here are the cheesy garlic bread and lentil soup, I could literally eat it forever. Their baked ziti pizza and baked ziti is great too. I haven't eaten something from here that I didn't like. Favorite pizza place by far."
"The Garlic Knots (Dozen) are SO good. also served with a beautiful side of sauce. The value for the Chic Cutlet Parmigiana with Pastaken is amazing. The food here is consistently delicious. If you're under the weather their Chicken Soup (Quart) is seasoned perfectly and is a healthy serving."
Neapolitan (Large)
W/ chicken.
$21.82
Garlic Knots (Dozen)
W/ chicken.
$6
Regular Slice
12 slices.
$3.72
La Vespa
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 38 min
"I had to make a last min order for some and thank goodness the people who were working!
Order was delivered before time. I only wish I could have tipped Semintra more, such a doll, TY:)
Vespa is my fam fav. For a few reasons.
Quality and consistency
Parted with kindness. Love this. The GF pizza is amazing too, fellow celiacs. God bless"
"Grilled Chicken Florentine is an absolute must. We get it every time we order from here. The Parmesan Trio Combo is also delicious and tonight was no exception. I also tried the Chicken Piccata for the first time, and it was perfectly. the chicken was soft, the sauce was tasty and there was plenty of artichoke."
Cheese Pizza (Pie)
6 per order.
$23.27
Cheese slice
A pink creamy meat sauce simmered with vodka.
$4.03
6 Knots
Breaded chicken bites in sweet n' spicy sauce.
$5.11
Mozzarella Sticks
12 per order, served hot or plain.
$11.36
Hero Haven and More
4.3
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.8 mi • 37 min
"I love this place. Honestly, they never mess up my order. The Breaded Mozzarella Sticks (For 7) are amazing and the pizza is really good too! Theyre just wonderful!"
"Always fresh quality food! Hero's are packed with ingredients, never skimpy. Fresh Mozzrella salad is amazing! "
Cheese
Freshly breaded chicken cutlet with crispy bacon and your choice of melted cheese.
$17.54
H16: Italian Stallion
Ham, salami, pepperoni, ham chappy, Provolone, sweet peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, salt, pepper, oregano, oil and vinegar.
$11.68
H9: Chicken Cutlet Club
Hot meatballs with melted Mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.
$11.38
Breakfast sandwich
Hot roast beef with gravy and melted Mozzarella on delicious garlic bread.
$8.25
La Margherita Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.6
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 4.6 mi • 33 min
"La Margherita is quickly becoming my favorite restaurant. Food was delicious. Very flavorful soup and salad, and the pasta primavera was the best I ever had! Special instructions followed, perfect lunch!"
"The Homemade Lasagna was a pile of mush when it got to me. The flavor was very bland and greasy. Couldn't eat it after a few bites.
The Chicken Francese Entree was exceptionally salty. We couldn't eat i. and had to throw it out. Side salad wasn't in the bag. So I paid 27.00 for 2 pieces of chicken.
Just an overall bad experience.
Probably wouldn't order from there again."
Regular Pie
Fresh sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil.
$23.51
La Margherita
Served with a side of marinara sauce.
$15.54
Garlic Knots (6)
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$4.34
Stuffed Garlic Knots (6)
Served with a side of marinara sauce.
$9.38
Alitalia Pizzaeria
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee
"Yes most definitely good size slices with good amount of cheese on them perfect actually! The sauce was delicious and fresh"
"Neapolitan pizza was delicious!!! Satisfied my pizza craving!! The best locally! perfectly cheesey and juicy with a good flavor and the crust was crispy but not tough."
Neapolitan
(8 slices) with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
$26.83
Garlic Knots
Creamy pink vodka sauce over penne pasta.
$7.63
Neopolitan
(12 slices) thin-crust Sicilian with mozzarella and spotted with a san marzano marinara sauce.
$5.87
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
(12 slices) with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
$12.45
Uncle Giuseppe's Pizza
4.4
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 12.1 mi • 58 min
Farther away (+$2.99 fee)
"Fresh, hot, & delicious! Did not expect for it to taste so good but it definitely is one of my new favorites! :)"
"Sicilian Square is not very good at all.
Sauce is bitter. Don't know what these people are talking about that claim it's very good. They have select items that are very good however pizza is definitely not one of them."
Neapolitan Round (8 slices)
20” thin crust pizza with mozzarella & California tomato sauce.
$20.88
6 Garlic Knots
Our 6 Garlic Knots are a delectable appetizer or snack, perfect for garlic lovers. Made with soft, fluffy dough twisted into knots and baked to perfection, then brushed with a garlic-infused buttery blend for irresistible flavor. Enjoy these savory treats on their own or dipped in marinara sauce for an extra burst of taste.
$3.37
12 Garlic Knots
Our Garlic Knots are a delectable appetizer or snack, perfect for garlic lovers. Made with soft, fluffy dough twisted into knots and baked to perfection, then brushed with a garlic-infused buttery blend for irresistible flavor. Enjoy these savory treats on their own or dipped in marinara sauce for an extra burst of taste.
$7.37
Create Your Own Round Pie (8 Slices).
CHOOSE YOUR TOPPINGS
20” thin crust pizza with mozzarella & California tomato sauce.
$25.15
Cafe Gia
4.6
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 36 min
"As always, all our meals were delicious...The grilled chicken in the salad was perfectly seasoned and the pasta with the ala Alla Vodka sauce is so so good! "
"Taste wise, everything was good. the canzone was not sealed, cheese ran out everywhere. The broccoli cost $15 and it was the smallest portion I've ever seen. Horrible. Calamari was good and was a large portion."
Neapolitan (8 Slices)
Round Pie with mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
$24.28
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed with our homemade caesar dressing, topped with croutons & pecorino romano cheese.
$14.77
Alla Vodka
Sauteed prosciutto in a homemade pink vodka sauce.
$22.24
Garlic Bread
Served with a side of tomato sauce.
Gluten free also available.
$6.91
Milano Pizza
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 32 min
"Love their pizza, calzones, chicken parm, meatballs, heroes. We have never had a bad item there. Portions are large. Milano's makes your food as you desire."
"I've never been so disappointed by a sicilian pie. The pizza was too salty, the cheese was not very good, and the store didn’t put enough plastic protectors in it to stop the box from picking up cheese off a full quarter of the pizza. The only reason I gave 2 stars is that the cannolis were pretty good, and my husband liked his sausage and egg hero."
Cheese Pie
Standard Cheese Pie with Mozzarella Cheese and Tomato Sauce.
$21.82
Greek Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Pepper, Green Peppers, Feta Cheese, and Olives.
$13.01
Garlic Knot Pie
Traditional Sicilian, Thick Crust, Square, Marinara, Cheese.
$28.3
Sicilian Pie (12 Slices)
With a side of Blue Cheese (Sauce).
$22.92
Medford Pastaria
4.4
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 36 min
"Great pizza as always. Was a nice crispy crust that hits the spot. Sauce is perfect. Cannolies are excellent. And massive. Def not cheating out on the filling. I typically get the rainbowcake That too is amazing. I will be getting both next time. lol eat the cake tomorrow, cannoli night of pizza. Best place around by far. "
"The Fried Calamari and the Pear Salad are delightful.
The Fried Calamari is crispy, not very oily, and has substance. Topping it off with lemon makes it pop. The sauce is robust, sits on the tongue well, and is juicy without being very acidic at all. I wish there was a way to order or include more.
The Pear Salad is fresh and balanced. The pears taste like Christmas, the candied walnuts are fun, and the lettuce and gorgonzola are crisp and fresh. The dressing is great but not necessary with all the above elements. It is a personal choice.
Portions are great. My partner and I are were able to split both items and have leftovers for the day after.
Note: you may want to either air fry or stick the Fried Calamari in the oven to reheat so it doesn't get soggy."
18" Large Pizza
Breaded chicken tomato sauce and cheese sandwich.
$28.63
Alla Vodka Sauce
Add a side of sauce for additional fees.
$26.1
Garlic Knots 6
Smooth tube shaped pasta.
$6.66
Chicken Parmigiana Entree
A long sandwich on a roll. add-ons for an additional charge.
$28.41
Bernie’s Pizza
4.6
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 2.3 mi • 43 min
"Regular cheese slices are a nice size and delicious!"
"Grandma pie is really delicious. The sauce is so good. The lasagna was excellent also. Great portion size and very flavorful."
Reg Pie - Large 16"
Classic cheese or create your own pie.
$26.25
Garlic Knots - 6 Pieces
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.
$3.86
Garlic Knots - 12 Pieces
Stuffed with Nutella, strawberries & bananas.
$7.05
Nutella Dessert Pie - Nutella Pie
Chopped beef, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream.
$19.5
Alfredo's Pizzeria
4.6
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.5 mi • 43 min
"This was some of the best stuffed rigatoni I've had in years. The garlic bread was delicious & excellent dipped in the sauce. The chicken pieces were extremely tender. The portion was so huge I had it for two dinners & lunch!You will not be disappointed!"
"Large Grilled Chx Salad is delicious!! Plenty of chicken and fresh crispy vegetables. Alfredo's is one of my favorites. Definitely would recommend"
- Cheese Pizza (T)
Shallot, garlic, plum tomato, cream, Romano cheese
$24.84
6 Garlic Knots
(6) classic wings tossed in your choice of sauce, served with blue cheese dipping sauce, celery and carrot sticks.
$4.71
Specialty Slice
Seasoned rice with ground beef, peas, sauce and cheese in the middle.
$6.86
Chicken Cutlet Parm Hero
Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper
$16.07
Cucina 25
4.7
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 13.4 mi • 70 min
Farther away (+$5.99 fee)
"Classic cheese pizza was very good. Perfectly cooked crust, delicious sauce, good toppings. The Penne Florentine sauce was very very good."
"Pasta Fagioli was not my favorite (weird pieces of pepperoni in it like it was rushed and it wasn't thick like I usually have it ) but in their defense, I was probably the last person to place an order close to 10 PM so they will probably closing up ..... And the Shrimp Fra Diavolo was top tier delicious this is my 4th time ordering it and it never disappoints!"
Classic cheese pizza
Romaine lettuce, croutons and parmesan cheese.
$21.61
Caesar Salad
golden fried chicken on toasted bread covered in fresh tomato sauce topped with melted mozzarella
$10.21
Penne Alla Vodka
Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, kalamata olives, onions, pepperoncini and feta cheese.
$18.37
Chicken Parm hero
Rich plum tomato sauce, thin crust and mozzarella cheese.
$12.28
Bella Roma Restaurant & Pizzeria (Coram)
4.7
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 51 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"Best Pizza in the north shore! I thought it was Pompei but nope Def Bella Roma!"
"Okay. I planned on taking photos BEFORE taking a bite. Impossible with that irresistible smell 😅 but this is a new favorite spot.
Portion size you say? Well Large Grandma's Pizza lives up to its name. 24 slices! This isn't one or the other either. It is both MASSIVE and DELICIOUS.
The Meatball Parm Hero goes beyond fresh. Let it be known I took a large "sample bite" prior to the photos. Wow. Genuinely blown away. Meatballs are gigantic and that homemade sauce is authentic Italian at its finest.
Old fashioned deliciousness.
Conclusion:
This is a 10/10 old school Italian restaurant all around. This isn't just a pizzeria. This is a true old fashioned Italian restaurant.
The Large Grandma's Pizza is ideal for parties or family get togethers. The Meatball Parm Hero is the best I've had on Long Island and I HIGHLY recommend giving it a shot if you love meatballs. Zero complaints.
Bella Roma gets an A++ from me and I will be back for more 😋"
Large Pizza Pie
Romaine lettuce croutons, shaved parmesan cheese caesar dressing on the side
$25.36
Reg Slice
Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers ,feta cheese, and peppers onions.
$4.34
Gino's Pizzeria (Patchogue)
4.6
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 42 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"Absolutely incredible, out of this world so good! I am in love with the meatball sliders! They are big and the garlic knot bread it is on is made to perfection, not over cooked. These are my favorites! You can never go wrong when choosing Gino's! "
"Pizza is tasty, as are Garlic Knots. Strong garlic flavor which I love! Rice Ball is very small. Overall, a solid pizza place."
Neapolitan
Our large round 16 inches cheese pie.
$19.76
Garlic Knots
Half dozen.
$5.47
Regular Slice
Select from our list of gourmet slices.
$3.86
Gourmet Slice
Meatball or chicken parm, buffalo, sausage, pepper & onion, spinach ricotta.
$5.03
Nonna's Pizzeria
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.0 mi • 46 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"Always delicious & hot! Pizza on the island not always great but love Nonna's. Vegie panini is always yummy....My fav pizzeria!!"
"Asked for utensils did not get them . Canoli custard was all over the container too thin. Spaghetti was too aldente. Chicken was good"
X-Large Cheese
(18" - 8 Slices)
$23.41
Caeser Salad
(6 Pieces) Fried strips of mozzarella served with Marinara.
$13.14
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried chicken, ricotta cheese, mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.
$10.43
Chicken Parmigiana Roll
Garlic knots, marinated in house made garlic butter.
$8.41
Original Michelangelo
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.3 mi • 46 min
"Still the best most tender veal on the East End. The pizza is also among the very best that NYC has to offer."
" You don't call it the original Michael Angelo for nothing. I am a superduper picky person. Chicken Parmesan absolutely fantastic. Broccoli bomb fish with clams. Probably would be even better as the fish is fresh. still a good dish. I can't say one item that has come to my home that was not good. Keep it up. Keep your original."
Neapolitan Pizza
A pink creamy meat sauce simmered with vodka.
$25.31
Garlic Knot
Romaine lettuce, croutons, caesar dressing and parmesan shavings.
$3.51
12" Ultra Thin Bar Pie (personal)
Romaine lettuce, croutons, caesar dressing and parmesan shavings.
$17.94
Uncle Joe's Famous Pizzeria
4.4
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 4.9 mi • 36 min
"Giuseppe Cheese Slice isn the best on the island BUT for the price, it's pretty stellar. The crust was the perfect texture and the cheese/sauce ratio was great. The Alla Vodka slice was much more similar to a white slice than a traditional vodka slice - a small amount of mild vodka sauce, topped with mozz and ricotta dollops. It is the newer vodka square style too, so dont expect triangles there. Overall would dine again, especially given the fair price point compared to other bellport/patchogue/medford options."
"Pizza was a little overly greasy, but cheese and sauce were good. Wish the crust was a little thicker; can't bend the slice in half because it flops over. Garlic knots are good, but way too much butter."
Giuseppe Cheese
Signature Cheese Pie that's made pizzaiolo Joe Sciara a Long Island legend since 1968.
$24.16
Brooklyn Garlic Parmesan Knots
Baked dough with melted garlic butter, parmesan, parsley
$6.13
Pizza Margherita
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, Pecorino-Romano
$23.99
Mozz Sticks
Mozzarella breaded with Italian bread crumbs, marinara
$10.45
Mary's Pizza and Pasta
4.7
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 9.0 mi • 47 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
Trending
"Best plain pizza we have ordered in the area by far! Second time we ordered a pepperoni pie. It arrived with a very generous amount of pepperoni slices. The pepperoni added definitely had more of a spicy kick than you would expect. Luckily, we all have a spicy palette so it was all good. Will try their eggplant topping next. Highly recommend."
"Mary's is a favorite of mine. The veal parmigiana is by far the best and BIG! Great bartenders and drinks too! You will not be disappointed."
Cheese Pizza
Romaine, garlic bread croutons, shaved parmesan and Caesars dressings.
$28.3
6 Garlic Knots
Romaine, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, roasted peppers, grilled chicken and balsamic vinaigrette.
$6.69
Caesars
Prosciutto, shallots, pecorino Romano and pink cream sauce.
$18.25
Mary's Chopped Chicken
Beef meatballs, marinara, ricotta and basil.
$25.49
Sayville pizza
4.6
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 12.2 mi • 51 min
Farther away (+$2.99 fee)
"Ordered from here cause my favorite place is closed, and wow! The sauce was amazing on this pie, savory with a little tiny kick of heat. The pizza was great and this will be my new place to grab a slice from!"
"The bread was so stale that it literally fell apart when a bite was taken. The sandwich looked nothing like the image. Tons of romaine lettuce and literally 3 small slices of grilled chicken. So disappointing."
Large plain pie
premium chicken with our delicious tomato sauce and mozzarella cooked to perfection
$22.07
Chicken roll
Bread, topped with garlic & olive oil or butter, herb seasoning, baked to perfection. melts in your mouth and arouses the taste buds.
$9.26
Garlic knots
Penne pasta in a creamy tomato vodka sauce, garnished with herbs.
$3.77
Penne alla vodka
Italian style meatballs, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
$14.19
Pizza Corner
4.5
(50+)$0 delivery fee • 6.8 mi • 44 min
Cheese Pie (Large 16") (8 Slices)
6 Pieces
$22.76
Cheese Pie (Personal 12")
6 Pieces
$14.81
Garlic Knots
Add Garlic Chicken for an additional charge
$5.49
Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled chicken topped with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and sliced tomato on panini bread.
$8.94
Matt's Pizza
4.6
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 58 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"The lasagna was excellent and such a generous portion. I've ordered lasagna from a few other local pizzerias and always been very disappointed with the quality as well as the portion size. Matts will ve my go to from now on!"
"Usually order pizza from here, I've had their sausage and pepper pasta, it's really good. However I ordered spaghetti Pasta with Alla Vodka Sauce and it has barely any sauce and taste like plain pasta. Very disappointed."
Neapolitan (18")
Hot, mild or BBQ
$20.9
Neapolitan (14")
Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried.
$16.91
Chicken Wings
Long thing pasta.
$12.14
Mozzarella Sticks
Made or covered with parmesan cheese
$10.55
Middle Island Pizza
4.5
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.1 mi • 46 min
"Good portion sizes, packaged up nicely, and fresh. The tomato sauce in the Side of Pasta is chunky and flavorful, the Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce added was delicious too. Salad is nice presentation even when to go, added chicken which was a nice portion "
"Omg it came hot and fresh ! Pizza was amazing they even brushed the crust with garlic knot spread for me !
Best Sicilian pizza I ever had ! 10/10 stars ! Top notch better than every place around them for miles ! "
Cheese Pie (l)
House made vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, romano cheese
$25.51
6 Garlic Knots
Chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, sliced and whole olives, roasted peppers and crumbled feta cheese with our famous house dressing
$5.14
Calzone
Crispy chicken, vodka sauce, whole milk mozzarella
$12.62
Sicilian Slice
Mixed greens, grape tomato, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, onions, roasted peppers, Asiago cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette.
$5.33
La Famosa Pizzaria
4.6
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 9.4 mi • 47 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"La Famosa is an excellent pizzeria with delicious food. The Garlic Bread with Cheese & Pepperoni had a generous amount of pepperoni, which is much appreciated. You should definitely try the Vodka Slice too. The Cannoli had a generous helping of cream too"
"It's honestly one of my favorite Caesar salads ever and I absolutely love the flavor of the Caesar dressing and they give you such a huge portion and the chicken is incredible. You have to get it."
Regular Pie
Classic cheese or create your own pie
$23.4
Garlic Knots
Chicken, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$5.37
Chicken Roll
Tossed in BBQ or buffalo sauce.
$12.46
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Romaine, croutons, homemade dressing.
$10.36
Alberts Pizza
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 11.8 mi • 51 min
Farther away (+$2.99 fee)
15% off on $35+
"Seriously the best Zucchini Sticks I've ever had! came delivered piping hot soo good! the Rice Ball with Sauce and Cheese was ahhmazing!! bigger than I even thought but my god delicious! and hands down my ultimate favorite is the Upside Down SLICE !! best around!"
"Cream of Spinach Slice was amazing, it sounds a little odd but was actually fantastic. Upside Down Square Slice was also very good. Dough was delicious and nice and crispy (for slices. I haven't tried a whole pie. Yet.) "
18" Neapolitan Pizza
Cheese under the sauce.
$22.61
Upside Down Square Pie
12 pieces.
$23.77
(6) Garlic Knots
Grandma crust with vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil
$4.5
Regular SLICE
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$3.6
Sapore Fino Pizzeria
4.5
(500+)$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 50 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"Very good and it was cheesy and they are not stingy on their meats too. "
"Always great service. I like the chicken Bacon Ranch. They often accommodate my odd tastes"
Neopolitan (8 Slices)
18" round. Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.
$20.92
Neopolitan
Thin crust pan pizza layered with mozzarella and grated pecorino Romano cheeses, then spotted with a garlic plum tomato sauce.
$3.37
Grandma Pizza (12 Slices)
Filled with meat sauce, peas, and mozzarella cheese.
$19.7
Buffalo Chicken
"Old World" style pan pizza baked with garlic and olive oil topped with garlic plum tomato sauce, pecorino romano cheese, and fresh basil.
$5.41
The Pizzeria
4.7
(5k+)$0 delivery fee • 10.8 mi • 46 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
"This was literally the best chicken parm hero I've ever had in my life. I called to see if they would switch the sauce to make it vodka sauce (no place to type in mods), and they could not have been nicer or more accommodating. It was just perfection. My husband also loved his Meatball Parm Hero. This will now be our go-to spot for heros! "
"Honestly best place on Long Island available on doordash for slices. Slices are huge, crispy and lots of toppings but not overloaded and all sloppy. Got the whole family hooked we all love this place 10/10 "
Large Pie
Traditional new york style slice
$25.07
Regular Slice
No Order is Complete Without Them
$4.05
Garlic Knots
Traditional ny style sicilian slice
$4.62
Sicilian Slice
Marinated chicken, mozzarella cheese and drizzle of our homemade buffalo sauce
$4.24
Pennachio's
4.6
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 6.0 mi • 48 min
"The best food and Hero I ever had !!!!!!!"
"Consistently good pizza prepared fast. Comfortable dining in, and my favorite for pick-up or delivery"
Regular Cheese Pizza
18". Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$19.32
Chicken Wings
Six pieces. Homemade chicken wings with your choice of plain, buffalo or BBQ sauce served with blue cheese and a side of celery.
$13.08
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
18". Square-shaped, thick crust pizza with mozzarella and red sauce.
$23.46
Pepperoni Pizza
18". Classic cheese and pepperoni.
$23.59
Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.6
(80+)$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 43 min
$5 off on $40+
"These are really about the best wings around!! Perfectly cooked and seasoned to my liking! Everything is hands down delicious! Must must try!!!"
"minestrone tastes and looks like canned progressive soup. The portion isn't filled up to the pt container they serve you. it's less than half.
Lunch special:
the garden salad is very fresh and colorful though and I love the homemade dressing. I just hope you can get Choose Any 2 Items Lunch Special your money's worth and the quality of homemade soup on a chilly rainy day. I would order again though, sometimes family owned businesses have their off days too."
Neapolitan Pizza
Crispy batter dipped mozzarella served with our traditional tomato sauce.
$22.72
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero
With chicken, mozzarella, and marinara sauce. Served with a side of sauce.
$13.56
Mozzarella Sticks
Spicy.
$10.99
Chicken Roll
Sausage, onions, peppers, tomato sauce, and mozzarella. Served with a side of sauce.
$10.99
Brothers Four Pizza
4.5
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 4.0 mi • 42 min
$5 off on $35+
"Best meatball sub I've had in years since the Bronx. That's saying allot. So heavy cause it was stuffed with fresh meatballs tomatoes sauce OMG i ate that whole thing. That was so good not salty so filled with flavor I can't say enough but its sure worth the money"
"Large Fountain Soda was actually large in size unlike most food places. Mozzarella Sticks (6) were a 10/10, wished for more seasoning on the breading but besides that, they were amazing. Large Cheese Pizza smelled amazing and looked even better. The Garlic Bread was cut into pieces to eat and smelled wonderful. Loved ordering from this place. Definitely will order from here again. "
Large Cheese Pizza
Made fresh daily!
$21.24
Garlic Knots
Green salad with caesar dressing and cheese.
$4.57
Chicken Parmigiana Hot Hero
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$10.84
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
$9.02
Giovanni's Pizzeria Gelateria
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.1 mi • 40 min
"omg the baked ravioli are like eating a piece of heaven! and the meatballs are moist...not like other places where they are dry and full of bread. the sausage is DeLish!!! the sauce makes all the difference! i won't be going anywhere else for pizza and pasta anymore. this place is the best in Patchogue!!!"
"We love everything we eat here. Personal pie favorite is the Arrabbiata, its pepperoni, crushed red pepper flakes, and black olives and omg its delicious. We have also had the Lasagna and its the best Ive eaten anywhere its delicious. We have even shared it because to be honest we cant pass up sharing the personal pie as an appetizer. Today we stopped in for slices and we love the grandma pie so I grabbed one slice and my husband got a grandma ala vodka and both were amazing. Then i tried a chicken w/mango habanero slice and it blew me away, it was spicy, sweet, the crust was thin and perfect crunch and my now all time favorite slice! Yum. "
18" Cheese Pie
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic and parsley. served with a side of sauce.
$30.43
Garlic Knots
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$5.81
Meatball Hero
Penne in vodka sauce.
$17.03
Coke 2L
Savory filling wrapped in square ravioli, breaded and deep fried until the pasta shell becomes slightly crispy and golden brown. these won't last long at your table.
$4.78
South Paw Brewing Company
4.6
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 3.5 mi • 36 min
"This place does not disappoint. At first it may appear pricey however the quality and generous portions make it feel absolutely justified!"
"$23 for a pizza that's actually just personal sized is.....a choice for sure. Didn't receive second drink either. Vodka sauce pizza was not only small but bland as well"
Classic Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, Tomato Sauce, Romano Cheese
$19.69
Wings
9 battered fried crispy wings tossed in your choice of sauce.
$19.23
Boneless Wings (12)
12 breaded chicken breast chunks fried and tossed in your choice of sauce.
$19.18
NY Vodka Sauce Pizza
Fresh Mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, Basil, Romano Cheese
$23.73
Alanza Pizza by Wonder
4.4
(20+)$0 delivery fee • 10.5 mi • 47 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
Cheese Pizza
Topped with rich marinara and creamy mozzarella, this simple and delicious pizza is the starting point for all of Alanza's classic red sauce pies. 12" pie - 6 slices
$11.98
Pepperoni Pizza
Marinara and mozzarella are topped with crisp pepperoni cups in Alanza's version of the classic favorite. 12" pie - 6 slices
$12.47
Vodka Pizza
A spin on a classic cheese pie, this version replaces marinara with creamy, mildly spicy tomato vodka sauce. Finished with mozzarella, shaved Parmesan, and basil. 12" pie - 6 slices
$11.98
Hot Honey & Salami Pizza
Spicy salami and Calabrian chile give this pie a bit of heat while honey gives it just a hint of sweetness. Also topped with mozzarella and provolone. 12" pie - 6 slices
$12.97
Taco Bell
4.1
(15k+)$0 delivery fee • 600 ft • 22 min
"The Cinnabon delights are my favorite. And the island beverages are creamy and refreshing. Both are very good. "
"The Chalupa Supremes were the worst I ever had. The shell was terrible. It was hard and crumbly and tasteless. Very little beef and it was bland.
I have ordered them in the past and they were usually good. If these were the first I ever ordered I would never order them again. I would probably never eat at Taco Bell again. "
Chicken Quesadilla
A large flour tortilla filled with a blend of mozzarella, pepperjack, and cheddar cheeses, grilled, marinated all-white-meat chicken, Creamy Jalapeño sauce, and grilled to perfection. (490 cal.)
$7.68
Crunchwrap Supreme®
A warm flour tortilla filled with seasoned beef, warm Nacho Cheese sauce, a crispy tostada shell, lettuce, diced tomatoes, and reduced-fat sour cream folded into our signature Crunchwrap form and grilled to go (530 cal.)
$7.91
Cheesy Gordita Crunch
A warm, pillowy flatbread filled with a blend of mozzarella, pepperjack, and cheddar cheeses wrapped around a crunchy taco shell with seasoned beef, Spicy Ranch sauce, lettuce, and shredded cheddar cheese. (480 cal.)
$7.17
Grilled Cheese Burrito
A warm flour tortilla with seasoned beef, warm Nacho Cheese sauce, seasoned rice, crunchy fiesta strips, Creamy Chipotle sauce, reduced-fat sour cream, and a blend of mozzarella, pepperjack, and cheddar cheeses with even more cheese grilled on the top. (690 cal.)
$7.64
Joe's Pizza & Pasta
4.7
(8k+)$0 delivery fee • 11.2 mi • 51 min
Farther away (+$2.99 fee)
"We loved our pizza and Chicken Parmigiana hero. The hero was huge. We ate half and will enjoy the other half for lunch tomorrow. The people working at Joe's are great and get you in and out very quickly if you pick up the food yourself."
"Amazing!! The Baked Ravioli (6) was so soft and tasty. The Homemade Meatballs (3) were thick and filling. The Tossed Salad | Large was a lot of salad, but I wish it had cucumbers. The bread they give you for free with the entree is way better than the one you order on the menu. "
Neapolitano Cheese Pizza | 18"
8 slices. Regular pizza.
$27.7
1 Liter Soda
1 liter soda
$3.93
Penne Alla Vodka
Our famous pink cream sauce with or without ground beef.
$23.77
Cheese Personal Pizza
Cheese personal pizza
$17.98
Michelangelo of Speonk
4.7
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 8.6 mi • 51 min
Farther away (+$1.99 fee)
15% off on $75+
"visiting from vt, the food was amazing. Everything was nice and hot when it arrived. Garlic bread was super garlicy which I love. Baked Ziti was delicious and chicken was cooked perfectly and well seasoned! This restaurant is fantastic!"
"Pricey, but tasty. Taste wise it's great, but I added meatballs to my pasta dish which was a $7 up charge. Fair enough. A side order is only a few extra bucks and includes more than one meatball. My pasta had ONE singular meatball (for $7!!!). This is kinda crazy, however at least it's a nice meatball. Would order again but I won't be adding in a meatball for $7 next time. 2 meatballs would be a bit more fair in my opinion."
Cheese Pie
Hand-tossed, 16" pie with the classic tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Spiced with grated romano and oregano
$22.26
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Pink creamy sauce simmered with prosciutto and vodka
$22.82
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, caesar dressing & parmigiano cheese shavings
$14
Garlic Knots (6)
hand-knotted fresh homemade dough, proofed fluffy, cooked golden, and tossed with garlic, grated cheese, and parsley
$4.09
Savianos Pizza & Restaurant
4.7
(600+)$0 delivery fee • 13.3 mi • 46 min
Farther away (+$5.99 fee)
"The best pizza and Italian on the island!"
"Best Homemade Meatballs around my favorite and Buffalo Chicken (Sliced Pizza) was huge and delicious with an extensive menu I look forward to trying more every thing is fresh and made daily"
Neopolitan Pie (Regular)
Served by the half dozen
$28.04
Garlic Knots
Hearty ground beef sauteed in a creamy pink vodka sauce tossed with penne
$5.83
Penne Alla Vodka
Baked Italian bread basted with fresh garlic, evo and imported spices
$26.47
Neopolitan (Sliced Pizza)
Fried chicken cutlets topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
$4.8
Chuck E. Cheese
4.1
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 7.2 mi • 40 min
"Best pizza as always :)"
"pizza was perfect but the French fries not sound good there was a total of like 10
"
Cheese Pizza
Our freshly-made classic cheese pizza, with a garlic butter dusted crust.
$24.97
Cheesy Bread
An all-time favorite App! Shredded mozzarella & cheddar cheeses on a garlic butter dough. Served with red sauce and lite ranch dipping. Serves 2 - 3
$8.51
Large Build Your Own Pizza
Choose your toppings and select your crust to create your perfect pizza. Pineapple on your pizza? Triple chicken? ALL the veggies? Go for it!
Serves 3 - 4
$27.6
Unicorn Churros
Our one-of-a-kind cotton candy, sour apple, and blue raspberry sugar dusted dessert. Serves 1 - 2
$6.12
Umberto's of Sayville
4.7
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 12.1 mi • 44 min
Farther away (+$2.99 fee)
"SO glad my favorite pizzeria on Long Island is finally on DoorDash! Their Sicilian is amazing and their deep dish is equally delicious! No one else touches this place-The best! Pizza is perfect every time. "
"The Broccoli, Garlic, Oil was not packaged properly so it leaked all over the bag and everywhere (this happened the last time I ordered pasta as well). It tasted bitter so I threw it out. The Mb Burrata had exactly 1 and 1/2 meatballs slices on it. The Chicken Roll was burned and the chicken is dry"
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce with croutons and caesar dressing
$15.3
10" Cauliflower Crust Pie
10" gluten free caulioflower crust with tomato sauce and cheese.
$19.54
Deep Dish Pie
Round Deep Dish with Mozzarella and Pizza Sauce
$25.88
Buffalo Wings (12)
Cream sauce with genuine Parmigiano
$17.25
Shirley Pizza Delivery FAQs
Is Pizza delivery available near me in Shirley?
Yes, Pizza delivery is available near you in Shirley through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Pizza options available for delivery near you.
Where can I find the best Pizza delivery near me in Shirley?
To find the best Pizza delivery near you in Shirley, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Pizza spots near you.
Where can I find cheap Pizza near me in Shirley?
For affordable Pizza delivery near me in Shirley, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.
What is open now for Pizza delivery near me in Shirley?
To see which Pizza restaurants are open for delivery in Shirley right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Pizza places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.
Can I schedule a Pizza delivery in Shirley?
Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Pizza delivery in Shirley at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.
How can I get free Pizza delivery in Shirley?
To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Pizza orders in Shirley, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.
How do I pay for my Pizza delivery on DoorDash in Shirley?
Payment for your Pizza delivery in Shirley is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!
What are the most popular Pizza dishes I can order near me in Shirley?
Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Pizza dishes from restaurants near you.
Top Cuisines in this City
American in Shirley near meChicken in Shirley near meMexican in Shirley near meGrocery in Shirley near meHealthy in Shirley near meMediterranean in Shirley near meItalian in Shirley near meBakery in Shirley near meJapanese in Shirley near meCafé in Shirley near meHalal in Shirley near meSpanish in Shirley near meBrazilian in Shirley near meAsian in Shirley near meChinese in Shirley near me
See more