Amanda Wilbanks, a University of Georgia graduate and creative entrepreneur, founded Southern Baked Pie Company (previously Buttermilk Pie Company) in Gainesville, Georgia in 2012. Amanda and her team…
The chicken pot pie was fantastic! The crust was flaky and buttery. The inside was filled full with lots of chicken. It's definitely comfort food when you missing home a lil. I'll be going back for sure
C
Caroline H
2 contributions
Loved
• 5/9/25
• DoorDash order
I have to say ive had a LOT of pot pies homemade and store bought but there's something about this place that makes it taste different. It tastes like it was made with love and care. Not to be dramatic but it's true. It was an entire experience, it tastes familial which is rare ordering to go! It's buttery flaky outside with juicy chicken and vegetables, it's the perfect combination. I haven't tried other pies yet but of course this one takes priority when trying something new. Even the apple pie was amazing! This is a place I would spend money on to get a meal that tastes like it was made from home! The customer service is equally wonderful! I went there in person and was greeted with kindness and it felt like I was at a family members picking up dinner! I wouldve added photos but I didnt think about it until after it was gone haha thats just how great it was !
F
Francine H
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/19/25
• DoorDash order
The chicken pot pies wer super small!!! Also got the chocolate and apple. The apple was so soggy I had to throw it out after two bites. Not worth the price at all for what I ordered. e
S
S.C. B
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Liked
• 8/18/22
• DoorDash order
Always love their pies but the crust on this one tasted raw. No worries bec we ate just the middle and was a peanut butter lover's dream
