Butter Maid Bakery
4.7(100+)•
DashPass•
Bakery•
Store Info•
DashPass
Closed
Order now, get it later
4.7(100+)•
$$•Bakery
Buttermaid Bakery is a small 5th generation family-owned bakery. The first bakery in Ohio and the 18th century bakery in the old country, handcrafted in the old fashioned way for over 150 years since …
Full Menu
7:00 am - 3:15 pmFeatured Items
Opens 7:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Clothespin Cookies Aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns
$25.99
Peanut Butter Buckeyes
$19.99
Apricot Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles
$25.99
Butterballs - Toasted Walnut Cookies
$19.99
Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies
$10.99
Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons
$19.99
Reviews100+ ratings • 5 public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
S
Susan T
Local Expert • 125 contributionsLoved
• 5/5/22The honey walnut kolachi roll was very good. There was plenty of filling. The pastry was tender. The M&M chocolate chip mound was very chocolatey and large. I would recommend both items to anyone that is interested.
A
Andrei M
24 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/5/23Photos of their rolls look spectacular, so I bought one for the ridiculous price of $20. But the real thing has nowhere near as much filling as they advertise. Dissapointment.
S
Sara T
5 contributionsDidn't like
• 2/17/26These are the most over priced, cheap ingredients, frozen and bad tasting bakery items I have ever had.... I would not order from here again.
N
Nick D
3 contributionsLoved
• 8/13/23The Pecan Kolachi Roll is the best I've ever had, hands down. Nothing even comes close.
N
Nicholas M
1 contributionsLoved
• 11/5/21Effin beautiful pastries, just like grandma made !
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Pies
Deep dish pies with our signature crispy crumb topping
Cookie Mounds
Insanely large and super rich cookies meant for the brave, or sharing.