Luigi's is our new favorite treasure. Id never heard of it but it's always excellent and the prices are very good compared to other restaurants with similar menu items. I also like the interesting array of specialty pizzas. Five stars all the way!
M
Mariah W
2 contributions
Liked
• 1/12/26
• DoorDash order
Mixed experience—good food, poor value.
I’m more than willing to pay for good food, but I expect the portion and quality to match the price. Quality was there, but the portions were definitely not.
We ordered a 16” thin-crust build-your-own pizza (sausage, mushroom, green pepper, red onion, mozzarella, red sauce). It was $34. While it tasted good, the toppings were very sparse—thin slivers of peppers and onions, a small handful of mushrooms and sausage. It simply wasn’t $34-worth of pizza.
The pizza pinwheels were solid and worth the $10.
The Italian toast was also good—three pieces for $9 felt fair.
What really sealed it for me was the soda. The menu doesn’t specify size, and paying $4 gets you a 16 oz plastic cup of fountain soda with ice. That felt excessive and disappointing.
Overall, nothing was bad—but for nearly $75, the value just wasn’t there. I won’t be ordering again, but wanted to share details so others can decide if the pricing works for them..
D
Donna G
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/27/25
• DoorDash order
The Caesar salad was terrible with lettuce that had turned brown - definitely not fresh. The pizza was overcooked and dry. This is the second time I've given Luigi's a try. I had the same experience last time. I should have learned then that their food is subpar. I will not be coming back.
S
S R
53 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/23/25
• DoorDash order
The aioli on the Meatball and Mozzarella sub tasted way too much like mayo, which is gross on a meatball sub. Sub also wasn't cut in half. Pizza arrived burnt and ice cold, not a great combo. The crust is hard enough to break teeth. The FOUR DOLLAR soda arrives in a small cup. For what you pay for this food, very, very disappointing.
C
Cheyenne M
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 3/13/23
• DoorDash order
The pizza was good, it was warm without being hot to the point of burning my tongue. It had just the right amount and texture of cheese with a square cut thin crust. Toppings were all fresh.Bruschetta was decent. The prices were about the same as other decent pizza/Italian places. I like it.
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Pizza of the Month
Try our monthly pizza!
Starters - Food
Thin Crust Pizzas - Food
Featuring our cornmeal dusted crust, topped with the finest meats, fresh vegetables, and Wisconsin cheese. We are happy to prepare our pizzas to meet most dietary needs or preferences (vegetarian, vegan, gluten sensitive, and more). Please notify your server of allergies.
Build Your Own - Food
House-Made Pastas - Food
Toasted Italian Subs - Food
12" subs baked to order on seeded Italian bread. Served with a bag of potato chips
