The "BIG" cookie was about the size of 2 Chips Ahoy (see picture) tasted fine but not worth $4. The Knish was not up to par. I put it in the air fryer which helped crisp up the outside but it still had little to no mash potato filling. Disappointing for $8. The pizza was OK.
Z
Zachary A
1 contributions
Loved
• 8/3/24
• Commande DoorDash
I was born & raised in NY and have consistently been let down by foods calling themselves pizza. This is the closest I've come to home in almost 2 decades!! The garlic knots have real garlic and the pizza folds, nuff said.
L
Lexi H
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/16/24
• Commande DoorDash
I would have included pictures, however, the pizza barely made it through the front door. I absolutely devoured it. Best crust. Best sauce. Perfect cheese. Giardineara was the best I've ever had. Ordering again asap.
A
Andrea B
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/12/26
• Commande DoorDash
It's been awhile since I've ordered from Brooklyns Pizza this time it wasn't good. It was bland and the crust was tough
W
William T
4 contributions
Loved
• 3/18/24
• Commande DoorDash
this is by far the best NY style pizza in the Denver area. I've tried them all. the pepperoni pizza is top notch, and the tiramisu was unbelievable.
