Welcome to Antlers Restaurant, a cherished dining destination in Ithaca, NY, where tradition meets exceptional hospitality. For decades, we’ve been a local favorite, serving up hearty, high-quality me…
We both got the ANTLERS ORIGINAL BURGER. He got fries, I got green beans. I don't even like green beans, but these were delicious. The burger was huge, a bit more rare than my usual, but juicy and delicious. Will order again 100%.
I
Irem A
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/17/25
• DoorDash order
It's always a gamble -if you dine in you wait too long - if you order for pick up it's always late and they kept changing the time for pickup as we got there. Seasonal Fresh Vegetables seems like it's always green beans and you pay $5-6 for 10 stems of beans.. never ordering it again. Burger is missing a flavour. It doesn't not worth over $20. Too bad our neighbourhood restaurant is just overpriced..
N
Nathan K
4 contributions
Loved
• 9/1/23
• DoorDash review
Easily the best place to get from anywhere near me, I can't wait to go there in person but so far I've just tried their food on door dash. The burgers are amazing every time and their sides are great too. They even offer some seriously premium cuts of steak and other meals you can't get anywhere else around here 100/10
K
Kaleigh C
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/7/24
• DoorDash order
The Antlers Original Burger was a good burger. I felt it was lacking flavor, but could tell the meat was good quality. The bun was good. The Appetizer Scallops Au Gratin was terrible. I actually threw it away. it was salt overload. I thought it would have been a little bigger in size for the price, but I understand everything costs more now. It was 4 scallops about the size of a quarter each. I felt they were overcooked. I had one. It was completely ruined by salt overload. The SIDE COLESLAW was terrible as well. The texture was like a slip and slide on a hot summer day. I understand I got take out so that could the problem. No freshness though taste wise. The flavor was completely lacking. One bite and into trash. The HOT HONEY CORN BREAD ... eh... I don't know. I was hoping for again, a different flavor profile. it wasn't bad, just wasn't all that. The Chocolate Mousse Cake was good. I don't know if they make desserts in house or order them, but either way, it was good. The mashed potato was my side for the burger. They were terrible. They were like dried hunks of glop. I think the potatoes were a good quality though, but lacking something... moisture, flavor as well. Seems like they could have added some salt from the Appetizer Scallops Au Gratin to the potatoes.
I've always heard good things about this restaurant. I've ordered from there before once and had a so so experience, but jeesh.
I was in a little of this little of that mood when I ordered and it just sucked.
Maybe dine in service is better? I don't know.
C
Christina C
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/7/25
• DoorDash review
Ordered from the west coast to celebrate friends' Golden Wedding anniversary in the east coast while being confined at home. First time with this restaurant for all.
Food reported delicious and wonderful. They had Bourbon glazed duck, El Diablo salmon, shrimp etouffee, crab cakes, ahi tuna, shrimp cocktail, Caesar salad, Santa Barbara salad, cheesecake, peanut butter cake, chocolate mousse. Plenty for five to share though ordered for three.
They have added Antler's on their restaurant list. Delivery was timely with text and email notifications. Tip well for good service. They all work hard.
