Unsweetened Cold Tea wasnot what I was expecting... it was bottled peppermint tea...Dr. Pepper (glass bottle) was good...10+1 smallslice of pie...I thought for that price I was getting a whole Pie... crust was too thick and hard. not much cherries.
M
Myrrh W
Emerging Expert • 39 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/13/23
• DoorDash order
The Smooth Operator was really good, but the Ebony & Ivory was dry, tasteless and consisted of 50% crust. The images shown are really deceiving, giving you the impression that you're getting a mini pie, when all you're getting is a VERY small slice that measures no more than 4-4.5" across. For $10 a piece... Go to Buttermilk Sky Pies instead, way more worth it.
D
Dede C
Local Expert • 46 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/29/24
• DoorDash order
I thought I got a whole pie for 10.40 plus fees and tip. But it was one piece and it was very small. Very cute packaging though. Tie the string so I can pull one end and it opens.
H
Honora C
11 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/22/25
• DoorDash order
Smooth Operator andThe Drunken Nut were successful. good with very good crusts.
Nutty Honey was not great, caramel at the bottom was overpowering and way too sweet
Buttercream was bad. bad crust.bad texture. dry and flavorless and sweet
nice packaging but uncomfy forks, you can't eat off a wooden forks
C
Chedel T
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/30/23
• DoorDash order
Apple pie was okay.
More disappointingly was the nearly $12 I spent on this one Slice of pie (I clearly missed the part where it said slice vs whole pie, as indicated in the picture).
The store doesn't have options for making the order meet Dash Pass guidelines so I ended up spending nearly $20 for the delivery of a mediocre slice of pie!
