At Mr. Gyro’s, we serve up bold flavors and satisfying meals that keep our customers coming back for more. Conveniently located at 5358 West 38th Street in Indianapolis, we specialize in fresh, flavor…
The Smash Burger wasn't a true smash burger and it was the size of a cheeseburger from Mcd's. There was no seasoning to it at all. The Gyro Plate had way less meat than you get with other places. Also no seasoning. The overall taste to everything is bland. And I don't understand why they never salt the fries. The fries are always terrible. I will just stick to the wings. They are always good.
J
Joly R
5 contributions
Loved
• 3/23/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered my 12) (1/2 Lb.) Double Cheeseburger and called to ask for no cheese and they just did it, no questions asked. ive loved eating their food since i was little. and its still awesome. great fries and a greater still burger.
T
Treasure I
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 12/12/23
• DoorDash order
Huge 35. ½ Lb Double Cheeseburger. Was almost like a whopper, I put in the instructions to add lettuce, tomato, mayo, etc. and it came exactly how I asked for it. 60. Spaghetti came in a HUGE portion size also. You know the white styrofoam takeout containers, without dividers? Yeah, it was full to the brim, I added meatballs and it was so heavy I almost dropped it. Great price for the amount. 91. Pizza Puff 's were also very reminiscent. Almost exactly the same taste I remember as a kid. I'll be ordering again, hopefully they have Reuben's back in stock by then.
S
Stephanie S
Local Expert • 120 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/31/26
• DoorDash order
This is my first time ordering from Mr. Gyros. 3) Gyros Plate half was holding a paper fry tray of"salad", the other side, a stale pita topped with varying degrees of old, dry, hard, hard to bite and chew, gyro meat. I would not ever expect to be served. The meat was slathered in white sauce which I didnt order. I am very disappointed at the iceberg lettuce and unripe slices of tomato piled on top of vinegar soaked onion slices. Pretty large chunks of feta cheese - fresh and delicious. My lettuce and tomato were also fresh, although not ripe. I ordered a side of feta, bacon, and gyros meat. My 2 slices of bacon were rolled soft in a dixie cup. I don't think this was real bacon. My gyros meat was crisper.
78) French Fries x 2..because I like to eat them together and I was unsure of their portions. 78) French Fries were warm, half soggy, half perfect, unsalted, included salt for your own tastes (which I appreciate) They were fire!! I would probably not order from here again 😒
C
Craig F
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/19/25
• DoorDash order
Didn't receive my salad. Chicken was dry and Gyros was just thrown in the box with no sauce and very little meat.
