I paid almost $50 for a pepperoni and spinach pizza and some pieces of my pizza only have 1 piece of pepperoni and some have 2. Spinach?!?! Where is the spinach. I've only counted 4 leaves on the entire pizza. Completely unacceptable.
A
Alex R
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/15/25
• DoorDash order
Literally so cold and the pizza definitely looks underdone. I've never received a pizza with crust that's white and soggy before so this was a disappointing first. Both items are cold and gross. The cheese sticks are stuck to the cardboard box. Rotolos is way too expensive for it to come in worse condition than fast food pizza. We'll stick to Marco's next time.
J
Jeremy S
15 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/7/24
• DoorDash order
If this is what you're into by all means enjoy but when I pay 27 for a pizza and 7 for a side Cesar w/bacon I expect more. It's greasy, small and the taste is mediocre. Some folks rave over this place I guess it's not for me .
S
Sheri M
Local Expert • 74 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/24/24
• DoorDash order
This was our 2nd deep dish order from you, hoping it would improve after the first experience. The taste of the Windy City (Deep Dish) pizza (& the other one) was fine, but the size & prize are OUTRAGEOUS! You can buy a full-size (aka "Large") AUTHENTIC deep dish pizza from Lou Malnati's or Giordano's IN CHICAGO for under $30 & it would serve FOUR (4) PEOPLE!
Plus, the bottom crust is so wet & soggy it soaks completely through the bottom of the box & leaks all over everything! You could at least put a liner underneath it - if you can't bother to cook it properly!
The Side Salad (Garden) was about five bites.
We'll drive to Chicago for deep dish before wasting our time & money here again. Sorry.
J
Jana R
4 contributions
Loved
• 2/26/26
• DoorDash order
The food was wonderful! The muffaletta was so very good! Only comment I would make, it needed more olive spread! So yummy. The Greek Salad was big enough for two.
Service was fast!
