In Lancaster, New York, The Pizza Heist is the place to go for a cheap supper. We've been making gourmet pizzas since 2012, and our Rodeo Pizza with onion rings is a must-try! Chances are we'll be ope…
The Steak sub was overflowing with steak and cheese!! It was so good I ate half of it and didn't take a picture till I ate the second half an hour later. And the garlic bread with sauce is the best thing on the menu. I made the mistake of going to Picassos for the same order and it was absolutely horrible. So if you a really fresh and cheesy garlic bread, order it and you won't be disappointed. I want to add that the nice polite long brown haired lady who works the front cash register and gets orders is the sweetest and most professional ever!! She deserves a raise and I wish I knew her name, please make sure she gets a raise. She goes above and beyond every time I'm there!!!
F
Frank D
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/5/24
• DoorDash order
First time trying this place and it was amazing. Crispy Boneless Wings and the tub of blue cheese is cheap and fresh! The Steak Hot Sub is killer with a good balance of toppings and the costanzos roll made it better. Will be ordering again I am picky with quality the pizza heist has it. Was delivered within 40 minutes too!
S
Shrek
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 1/2/26
• DoorDash order
The wings were sooo damn good! Great way to start new years! Will order from here for sure every time! The wings were not only fresh and tasty, but the 10 piece with bbq chard was definitely fantastic!
S
Saren L
7 contributions
Loved
• 3/27/25
• DoorDash review
OMG I love this place. I've never gotten anything that was not delicious. Specifically I typically get a Turkey Sub. The Steak Pizza is extraordinarily delicious. For a special treat try the Fried Dough. So Good!!!
K
Kevin D
2 contributions
Liked
• 4/29/26
• DoorDash order
I enjoyed the pizza very much. It was cooked perfectly and the onions were a+. The wings were also good. Ordered plain, they came crispy. I will say they forgot my medium sauce on the side order 😒 so i ate them dry. The Garlic Parm chicken fingers were WEAK in my opinion, no flavor and soaked in oil. The fries were OK but could have been a little better done. A large portion of the French fries were soggy as a result of the oil filled chicken finger container. Arrived hot and fresh, also the driver was pleasant.
