NY Pie
4.7(500+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
Open now
4.7(500+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:30 am - 10:25 pmFeatured Items
50 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
18" Cheese Pizza
$28.74
•100% (12)
#2 Most liked
18" Pepperoni Pizza
$32.19
•91% (12)
#3 Most liked
12" Pepperoni Pizza
$21.84
•85% (20)
#1 Most liked
12" Times Square / 42nd St
$26.44
18" Times Square / 42nd St
$40.24
18" Combo Pizza
$37.94
Reviews500+ ratings • 9 public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
K
Katherine L
1 contributionsLoved
• 3/16/25The best pizza ever. Hands down. Foldable NY slices that hit the spot. Fresh and very tasty ingredients. I will never have any other pizza. NY pie has ruined me.
R
Ryan L
4 contributionsLiked
• 6/11/26I like that it was thin, well cooked, had perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Absolute classic NYC slice. If you're really hungry I recommend going larger than normal because it's not a stacked or thick pizza.
C
Cynthia J
11 contributionsDidn't like
• 1/17/26Pizza's need more sauce and the Times Square needs more ricotta. The pizza dough needs more salt as it's pretty bland. Also one of the pizza's was smashed into the fold of the box which ruined a piece.
S
Sean C
4 contributionsLoved
• 12/24/24amazing pizza. ordered extra cheese and well done and got it delivered and it was still fresh and crispy. cheese was melted well and not burnt. Will 100% order again.
J
Jordan P
Local Expert • 488 contributionsLoved
• 1/20/25The pizza is scrumptious and the Garlic Knots are good enough not to require dip. Also, the pricing is not as outlandish as other places. Thank you!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store