Ordered my usual eggplant parm. Never a disappointment. A ham, salami and provolone sub, best I've found in the area. Eggplant rollatini appetizer... well, the rollatini was great, but the leaked mess from the crimp tin packaging was not appreciated. You guys have the nice plastic containers for everything else. Use those.
M
Matthew H
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Loved
• 3/29/25
• DoorDash review
Super delicious high quality food. The garlic knot "sliders" are insane and are full blown sandwiches. The stinger pizza is incredible. Ingredients are top notch.
My biggest problem with this place is that I want to order everything but dont have the room in my stomach for it.
S
Sonia S
Local Expert • 47 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/14/25
• DoorDash order
The Wings I ordered were delicious. They had the right amount of flavor and sauce, and the restaurant included the extra dressing and celery sticks I ordered. I was disappointed in the Chicken Vodka Slider, though. The order included two. They had a lot of cheese, but not nearly enough sauce. In fact, so little sauce that they actually tasted rather dry. I ate half of one and tossed the rest away. The garlic knot the slider came on was good, had good flavor, and tasted fresh, but it wasn't enough to redeem this food item for me. I would give the restaurant another shot, but I won't be ordering the sliders again.
J
Justine C
7 contributions
Loved
• 9/9/26
• DoorDash order
I absolutely love the kickin chicken on anything!
Pizza is one of jersey's best !
 The ingredients are always fresh and we love the curly's ice cream
V
Victoria C
Local Expert • 69 contributions
Liked
• 7/6/25
• DoorDash review
For the most part I really like everything I've ordered from pizza boys. The eggplant parm is excellent. The calamari might be the best around. The sauce is good too, but the pasta sides are really lacking sauce. I can boil my own pasta. (Please carry whole grain pasta). It's the sauce that makes the difference. Add some sauce, please. The pasta is always dry. They don't have mussels, which I thought was unusual so if mussels are calling me I have to order elsewhere. The pizza I wasn't crazy about. It's ok. I think it's oregano, which I think should not be added unless we add our own. Maybe others would love it. Packaging is very good, and is one reason I select this place over some others that insist on using big boxes, which I hate. Pizza boys uses a bag. Plastic entree containers. It's the prices I really have an issue with recently. I noticed entrees and even appetizers increased a few dollars each. This establishment is rather expensive anyway, compared to other similar places, so the extra costs now have me ordering elsewhere on occasion.
Would have given 5 stars aside from price.
