I critique this style of pizza harshly. I was fortunate to grow up on the East Side, and have the original Bocce Club pizza made by the legend Rudy. This Pie is legit! I'd say better than Imperial and Bocce (they've gone to commercial) someone here must have ties to that family because I was pleasantly surprised. This is OG Buffalo Pizza, stoked to have this so close to home, will 100% order again. Original Sauce is where it's at, this sweet trend going around WNY is not for me. If you're on the fence, and like this style of pizza, try it!
C
Chuck P
9 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/17/25
• DoorDash order
I ordred a large and 20 wings through DoorDash. The pizza was ordered with double pepperoni and barely came with any. It was way undercooked and had to be thrown in the oven to eat it. There were 20 wings ordered and I only got 10 of them. When I called and complained about it they told me sorry and you can come by and pick up the 10 wings we missed on your order. It was DoorDashed for a reason because people weren't able to drive and pick it up. I will never order from there again. They should be embarrassed and ashamed of themselves but they treat it like its normal and it happens ever day. Don't waste your money on a pizzeria that doesn't care about your food. I spent $70 for a pizza and wings to get a pile of garbage....unacceptable!!!!
C
Cy C
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/11/25
• DoorDash review
We tried their cheese and pepperoni pizza last week in their Hamburg location. The sauce was exactly how we like it. Very close to Pizza Oven's in Lockport. Sweet and delicious. However, the pizza itself was greasy. And not just a little greasy, a lot greasy! We so wanted to like it as it's close and good to have another pizza place. But we couldn't finish it due to the grease, unfortunately.
A
Adelheide B
3 contributions
Loved
• 4/13/26
• DoorDash order
The wings were CRISPY and still Saucy!and the Blue Cheese Sauce tasted homemade and perfectly fresh! Honestly? The best Blue Chese I have had in a long while. The fries were crispy too. Will be ordering again for sure.
A
Arianna L
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/6/26
• DoorDash order
So the Quarter Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own) is usually touching the corners of the carboard. This is a sad shape to be honest. But it was still good i guess
