Pizza in a Brick Oven: Pizza's Wonderful World! Since 1999, Yale has turned to Brick Oven Pizza for the best pizza in town. Students, staff, neighbors, and friends can't get enough of the excellent th…
Brick Oven is by far my favorite pizza in New Haven. Perfect crust, delicious sauce and generous with the toppings. It is getting frustrating lately that the past few orders I have picked up and had delivered had incorrect toppings or were missing toppings that I had paid for.
The salads are big and have better and more ingredients then you would typically expect from a pizza joint.
K
Kai F
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/29/21
• DoorDash order
Probably the worst pie I've had in this city. Floppy, too cheesy, texture of a Panera flatbread squished to its last breathe and then soaked in oil. Better late night pizza in this city for sure, and especially for less than $20 a pie. Yoikes.
L
Lindsay W
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/26/21
• DoorDash review
This pizza is SO good... definitely not the same Brick Oven as years past. Excellent crust, perfect sauce and toppings ratio-- and you can't beat the price. Highly recommend.
T
Tatiana S
9 contributions
Liked
• 7/5/24
• DoorDash order
Stuffed shells were super delicious! The carrot cake however, super small portion for $8 and was horrible, crusty and stale tastes like it's a month old.
N
Nikayla B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/26/26
• DoorDash order
This is the third time I have ordered pizza from this establishment, I don't know how I keep forgetting- for brick oven, and still manage to severely undercook their pizza. It is soft, doughy, uncut, falling apart, and actually disgusting if you do actually attempt to eat it. I literally just put on my fridge white board to never order from here again, do yourself a favor, get pizza from even dominos over this.
