Super cheesy but needs a little sweetness. Ever try a jelly spread. Was perfect and great quality products ! But even better with organic strawberry jelly. Fresh, huge and tasty !
N
Nicole R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/23/26
• DoorDash order
Joke of a sandwich. Almost $15 for two thin slices of Taylor ham and a cold piece of cheese slapped on. Then a jaalapeno cheddar bagel was literally a plain bagel with melted cheddar and a couple jalapeños thrown on top.
Please do not let the "NY" in the name fool you, because you would never get something like this from up north.
E
Emily K
5 contributions
Loved
• 3/26/26
• DoorDash order
I love this place!! Island Bagel used to be my go-to but Nosh is so much better! It's a little more pricey but the food is so worth it. The Chocolate Rugelach - 3 Pack and the Chocolate Babka are addicting. They don't hold back on portions and you can tell the food is fresh and made with love.
M
Michelle L
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/12/26
• DoorDash order
I'm sorry to say this was the worst breakfast sandwich I've ever had. The egg was overcooked and dry with a brown crust and bagel wasn't fresh. The top was crumbly and inside was like bread. I wanted to love this place after all of the hype of being like real bagels from home but it's not even close. Expensive too for what it is. I got single bagels the other day and they they werent fresh either. The Rosmary bagel was hard and I had trouble cutting it. I had to toast it and ended up throwing it out. I don't believe I will be ordering again. This was the third time.
B
Beth O
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 5 days ago
• DoorDash order
The bagels were oldish, not fresh in texture. The ingredients on the bagel were very fresh and delicious. I'll give them another chance since I ordered in the late afternoon. It's a breakfast item lol. I'm prolly a d bag because I am from the Northeast.
