One of the best pizzas I've ever had. Great charred crust and sauce was on point. For years I've lived in Boise and Nampa but never had the chance to try Keystone. I've heard nothing but great things, so when I saw it was nearby I had to give it a try. It's no wonder these guys have been in business for years. 10/10 for American pizza
C
Christina B
7 contributions
Loved
• 11/16/25
• DoorDash order
Sorry for the half gone picture, it was too good to wait. I love the really crunchy underside of the pizza and the fresh sliced tomatoes instead of diced. I got a 10 inch pizza (I think) and it's the perfect size for me to have a later night snack tonight. Also, if you get a side of ranch, it's huge. Definitely worth the dollar
B
B B
6 contributions
Loved
• 6/11/26
• DoorDash order
This is our 3rd time ordering Keystone Pizza through DD. It was delicious! I was finally able to take some pics before everyone went for it..lol
What we ordered:
Cheese Pizza with x-cheese (cheesy bit in a good way, crust crispy with the right amount of sauce)
Big House Combo (I had them leave off the green peppers,) delicious also, with generous toppings, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, onion, olives and cheese! Right amount of sauce with a crispy crust!
Chicken wings, with just the right amount of heat. My kids are always afraid of wings being too spicy but these are kid approved!
It come with 2 sides of ranch. I always think the taste of the ranch is so important when dunking your chicken wings in it. This ranch did not disappoint! Fresh and flavorful!
Cheese Sticks (with a side of pizza sauce) tasted good, right amount of cheese and the crispy bottom of the crust, with a good amount of puffed up dough right in the center.
If you want to do pizza night , I highly recommend ordering from here!
I absolutely love supporting local businesses.
B
B B
6 contributions
Liked
• 3/29/26
• DoorDash review
We ordered 2 pizzas, one cheese and I forgot the name of the other one but it was a speciality.
We also ordered the chicken wings. Everything tasted really good!! Very generous toppings, the crust was perfect! The chicken wings were delicious.
All the food tasted fresh and I finally found a place that is local . This will definitely be our go to...for pizza nights.
J
James C
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/22/26
• DoorDash order
Didn't follow directions 15" Large I paid for extra sauce. Asked for it to be put on the pizza. There was barely any pizza sauce on it. The crust seemed thinner. It was dry and little if any cheese. Not the pizza we normally enjoy.
