Big Guys Pizza is a family-owned pizza restaurant with two locations in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania's Brentwood and Bridgeville townships. The Parrish family and sons, Tyler (head of marketing and commun…
Today, Halloween 2026, I found my NEW "go to" pizza place in Pittsburgh, PA!
Which is 1 of my 3 homes.
I also live in Manhattan/NYC,
so I know a thing or 12 about amazing pizza!
After trying several PGH. pizza places over the last few years, today I tried BIG GUYS PIZZA on Bower Hill Road.
I got a Large cheese pizza & loved the many options available to customize it... from types of toppings, to exactly how much I want of each & how I prefer it cooked, to name a few.
Example: Well Done doesn't have to be burned. You can request Lightly Well Done.
&
Extra Sauce doesn't mean it's over soaked. You have options to pick the perfect amount.
Of course, they have many other Menu items, but finding a fantastic cheese pizza was my goal!
Also ~ my delivery guy was SO kind & I didn't mind that he rang the doorbell to hand the pizza to me. Usually I ask for orders to be left on my front porch, not sure if he was sent directly from the restaurant or if he is a DoorDash driver.
I'm glad I gave him a generous tip!!
On that note ~
IF, I had to give a couple small notes/suggestions to make it even better??
I got a Large pie with 2 toppings.
The toppings are finely chopped & tasty.
Pay for extra topping options, if you prefer more.
Also ~
The 10 slices were on the SMALL side.
FYI ~
A legit "NEW YORK STYLE" pizza means one thing... the slices are on the larger side.
With all that being said ~
I definitely will be ordering again, sooner than later!
&
Hope this review helps whoever reads it & is looking for a yummy pizza today!!
:-) Kim
M
Monica S
Emerging Expert • 155 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/23/26
• DoorDash order
Lasagna was made of overly spicy sausage and ricotta but the usual gooey cheeses were gone. it seems you buy the basic lasagna then have to buy every single topping separately making the take-out meal very expensive. Not recommended. The Breaded Mushrooms
however were very good.
P
Patrick C
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/1/26
• DoorDash order
in town on work, wanted to try a local place. Delivery was quick. garlic knots are humongous. pizza was delicious.
R
Renee C
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/26/26
• DoorDash order
The hoagie was dry !! The toppings were the least amount you can put on a hoagie. the onions were chopped not sliced. My first time ordering from here and won't be a returning customer. Lastly, the bread wasn't fresh !
B
Brian N
7 contributions
Loved
• 1/19/26
• DoorDash order
Very good all around. Pizza was great. Italian Hoagie was incredible. Breadsticks were excellent. Chicken Tenders are amazing. A new favorite for us! We'll be ordering here a lot more.
