Pizza was the best NY style pizza I have had in Florida. Excellent quality ingredients you can taste. Will order again and again. Cheese pizza delicious sauce, crisp crust.
B
Brianna N
2 contributions
Loved
• 4/24/26
• DoorDash order
Everything we ordered was great! The sauce was good, the crust on the Bronx Bomber Pizza was crispy and not super floppy considering how many toppings came on it. We ordered it to go, it was ready at the time they said. Overall not bad for pricing to portion ratio. Will be ordering from here again.
R
Riley N
2 contributions
Liked
• 5/3/26
• DoorDash order
My wife and I decided to try Times Square Pizza for the first time tonight. It’s conveniently located just a few minutes away from our house, making it an easy choice. We ordered the original Times Square Pizza with cheese and pepperoni, the garlic parmesan chicken wings, and the Arthur Ave pizza with vodka sauce, prosciutto, and basil.
The total came to around $52 after applying a DoorDash discount. I arrived promptly when the order was ready and took it straight home, which was a quick 2-3 minute drive.
The pizza arrived slightly warm, which was disappointing since it was a very quick drive home. While the flavor was decent, it wasn’t anything extraordinary. The Arthur Ave pizza was a bit of a letdown as the toppings weren’t evenly distributed. I was hoping for a stronger vodka sauce flavor, especially since the pizza was a bit salty.
On the positive side, I enjoyed the cook of the pizza and the crust was very enjoyable. However, for the price of $27, I felt it wasn’t worth it for me.
The saving grace of the meal was the garlic parmesan chicken wings. Even though it doesn’t say exactly how many wings you get online, we got eight wings for $14 which is about the norm since the Covid. The wings were crispy, flavorful, and not overly oily.
Overall, despite the convenience of being close to home, we found the pizza to be decently good, but not exceptional. We’ll consider ordering again to try a few different items, but we might stick to some regular pizza or wings in the future.
Update: I reheated the pizza up the following afternoon in the oven and I can say that with it being piping hot, it actually tasted significantly better. I felt that I had to come on here and just add that in here as I was pleasantly surprised.
J
John M
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Liked
• 6/13/26
• DoorDash order
This was my first visit, the Side Caesar Salad and The Arthur Avenue were pretty tasty. The pizza was fresh but the crust was a bit doughy. Though I really liked the vodka sauce on the pie. Portion size was average for pie and side salad. I think I would give them another try with other menu items. They jack the price up on delivery vs. pick up. By at least $4-5. So if you live close it's probably worth driving and skip the added cost of delivery.
M
Mike L
8 contributions
Loved
• 3/20/26
• DoorDash order
Absolutely delicious hear all this nonsense onlin about them did not care at all because they are right around the block from me I ordered just a pizza a some sticks my pizza was perfectly cooked like I like crispy just at well ingredients speak for themself kudos to the pizza maker this is now my go to pizza period it was best pizza I've found in the area 8.4
