Mike and Denise Busley, the proprietors of Grand Traverse Pie Company, used to know very little about cooking pies. With busy professions and two children, the Michigan natives had been living in San …
Best Chicken Pot Pie in town! One of my favorite cold winter night choices for dinner! The cherry pie, you ask? 👼🏻 Heavenly!
B
Brenda B
Local Expert • 248 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/26/26
• DoorDash order
The Chicken Pot Pie was well made with high quality ingredients, but not tasty. It was very bland and had an odd taste like nutmeg or similar spice. The Frosted Sugar Cookie was crumbled. GT Combo: The turkey sandwich was tasty. The broccoli cheese soup was extremely thick. Thicker than pudding. Quiche by the Slice was way overlooked to the point of dry and tasteless. The carrot muffin that came with it was actually moist and tasty. I will stick to buying pies from this place.
M
Michele W
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/5/23
• DoorDash order
They didnt know about our order until we showed up . The macncheese was cold and half filled, Tomato Bisque Soup was burned and cold and salty. Then there are the pies!!!! Soggy bottom on every pie! Cherry was a gelatinous mess! I paid nearly 70 dollars for this horrible meal.
Lisa H
Local Expert • 34 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/21/25
• DoorDash order
An absolute abomination, nay supreme ripoff. This is what $13+ gets you at Great Lakes Pie Company. A small, thin, sparsely layered Turkey Reuben Sandwich--pickle spear, and crucible of cole slaw on the side. "Grilled" sandwich was limp, cold, and greasy with a very bland flavor profile. In terms of quality, and especially value for the money Great Lakes Pie Company is an epic swing and miss. Hard pass, and never again either via DoorDash or in-store.
E
Elijah L
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/20/24
• DoorDash order
Food was decent but not worth the price, Turkey Reuben Sandwich was good but still overpriced, the pie was doughy on the bottom and top was brick hard a pretty big disappointment. If I knew it wouldn't even be cooked properly I definitely would have skipped paying over 5 bucks for one slice.
