The Black River Tavern is a unique, casual restaurant and bar situated in the picturesque Valley of the Eagles Golf Club. The natural beauty of the course is represented in the Tavern`s atmosphere. Fe…
OMG, highest compliments to the chef who prepared our Flatiron Steak. It was pure perfection and made to order. Considering my ex- boss is an owner of Red The Steakhouse in downtown Cleveland and I've been to other fine steakhouses, this is a seriously big compliment to be proud of. The Lobster Roll is yet to be enjoyed but I have a feeling that shall not disappoint. I will be ordering more soon.
G
Greg H
2 contributions
Loved
• 4/22/26
• DoorDash order
The Black River Chicken Sandwich is easily the best chicken sandwich in the area. Crispy breading, moist chicken. Fantastically seasoned. Nothing overwhelming, but also not boring. Very surprised on how big of a sandwich it was. Will order regularly
L
Lisa B
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 3/14/26
• DoorDash order
Golden Bear Burger and fries were a Great choice!, My hubby says its one of the best burgers in town and would most def order again! The Beef Brisket Mac is really tasty but the price could be dropped by five or so bucks or possibly add a lil more to the portion size for 25, other than that it was an awesome tasty choice and id order it again! Pulled Pork Sandwich and sideliner fries were a great pick too..all in all everything was hot, fresh, tasty and worth ordering again, Def not disappointed at all and happy we tried this place out. Outta all the diff places hes ordered a burger from, This Place has had the best one size&flavor wise!
C
Cheryl H
Emerging Expert • 49 contributions
Loved
• 7/20/24
• DoorDash order
this place is always the best however this last time the chicken was overdone almost burnt so it changed the flavor of it and it was just a little bit on the dry side but I will keep ordering because 99% of the time they're excellent and they have a good value they give enough food for 2 days and everything is exceptional
C
Christine K
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 5 days ago
• DoorDash order
The bourbon maple glaze was bland. The potatoes looked overcooked and the baked beans were blandness personified. The only really good thing was the small piece of pork belly in the beans. The walleye was cooked well but bland and the lemon aioli was weird and the truffle sidewinder fries weren't much to talk about. Both meals needed some salt. Finally no one has tried the brisket Mac yet but it didn't look nearly as good as the picture.
