We’ve always loved the simple, neighborhood bars of the Midwest and northeast. They’re there to serve the neighborhood – any and all. We took that accessible attitude and put it toward Haymaker. We se…
The Fried Okra Basket was fantastic (albeit a bit oily, but I like that), but the Mac and Cheese had legitimately no cheese. I can't make it up, it was just cooked noodles and breadcrumbs. I've been trying to love Haymaker but the quality is so inconsistent and the service is so consistently bad that I just can't justify coming here anymore. I've been a customer for a good couple of years too.
D
David G
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/6/23
• DoorDash order
The bread on the Italian Beef was terrible and hard. The meat and cheese was sparse. I had 5 total waffle fries in my order. 5. They were also overcooked and cold. I only ate one. Avoid this place.
L
Laura L
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/8/23
• DoorDash order
The Traditional Poutine was likened to the one that they have at mcdonalds in Canada, so it was pretty good. The Cuban Pressed Burger was okay as well. The Mac and Hay-Mac and Cheese was meh also. The tatertots were so salty they burned going down. Overall wouldnt recommend ordering for DoorDash. The delivery was fast and good.
R
Renee D
5 contributions
Liked
• 4/22/26
• DoorDash order
The Wisconsin Wurst is pretty good. Somewhat disappointed it did not come with the sauerkraut as described. I think maybe because I added grilled peppers and onions, that was all it came with. So, when ordering, be very specific as to the ingredients you want or they will only put the add ons and none of the ingredients in the menu description
