4.5 (see below for .5 deduction)
Every item delivered was absolutely divine! From the crispy crunch of the Rattlesnake Tails, to the smokiness of the sausage, every bite oozed flavor. The Scatter Bomb delivered was the wrong one, but it didnt even matter, because the flavor was so amazing!
Ranch dipping was forgotten, as was silverware, but with flavor like this it was easy to forgive.
Oh and the Mac & Cheese had the perfect balance of slight heat with a smooth cheesiness.
PS - grab Northern Lights or Toes in the Sand for a truly refreshing beverage.
K
Kayleigh H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6 days ago
• DoorDash order
Genuinely the most bland Mac and cheese I've ever had. Kraft would have more flavor. Same with the cheesecake, bland. I got the turtle one and there was no caramel but it was drowned in chocolate sauce. Not worth the price
A
Ally G
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/30/26
• DoorDash order
I usually love the Hickory and have had their chicken strips before - but they weren't the same. These were small, almost looked like strange chicken wings. They were super burnt and didn't have much meat in them. Pretty disappointing.
K
Katie W
1 contributions
Liked
• 10/11/25
• DoorDash order
The Cobb Salad was great, though the guacamole is a bit strange. The Mud Lake Cake was excellent, but it was swimming in melted ice cream. Please consider packaging the ice cream in it's own container.
D
Dirk M
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/28/26
• DoorDash order
Hickory went above and beyond to help us with an order that was placed close to closing time. Fresh food cooked perfectly, best place to eat in Rexburg!
Highly recommend the chicken fried chicken and Cajun shrimp!
