We just moved here and we won't ever order from anywhere else!
The food was authentic. The portions were generous, and the value is absolutely there for the money!!!
I wish we took pictures, but we were too hungry- please keep up the good work, Joey Garlics-- we're very impressed!!!
G
G S
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/20/26
• DoorDash order
Second time ordering. Got the Alfredo this time and added shrimp. A lot of pasta but not very good sauce. Big portions but I'd rather have better quality than more food. If it was cheaper I wouldn't complain but the price is just as high as better tasting restaurants. So now that I've tried them I'll move on.
S
Sandra L
1 contributions
Loved
• 10/17/24
• DoorDash order
me and my daughter ordered different meals I ordered the chicken parm & my daughter ordered the crazy Alfredo so we decided to share cause I wanted to try hers and she wanted to try mine lol... the meals are all HUGE ..we only took 1/4 outta each meal and the size on my plate is only a small amount from each meal..that too is what I love about this place the portions last me for 3 dinner nights lol....I usually get another regular with a drop of ricotta cheese on top of it with an awesome meat sauce I'm blank of the name of it but I order that every time cause it's so good it does have 100% customer rating on the menu . but sorry ya all I forgot the name of that one but if you see a pasta meal with a big spoonful of ricotta in the picture & 100% rating that dinner is the BOMB but I had to try something different at least once and once again I ENJOY both dishes the 2 mentiomed here i tried tonight were delicious. I love Joey Garlics..I recommend this place 100%!!!
J
Jeff B
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
Loved
• 12/9/25
• DoorDash order
The Lg The Sausage & Pepper Bronx was fantastic, one of the better pizzas I've ever had. The sauce was really good same with the sausage. It was huge also so definitely have leftovers. I do wish it was a little warmer but I don't think that's the restaurants fault.
The Chicken Parm was really good the bite or two I had and the portion like the pizza was absolutely massive.
N
Nicole S
Local Expert • 34 contributions
Liked
• 2/19/23
• DoorDash order
The pizza was perfect and tasted fresh out of a brick oven from NYC. The salmon and risotto was flavorful. On a minor side note the side salad that came with the main meal was extremely tiny, literally there was more in the 1oz dressing cup than the salad itself.
