Goodfella’s orlando
4.5(3k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info•
DashPass
Closed
Order now, get it later
4.5(3k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
From New York to the Heart of Florida Goodfella's Pizzeria has been going strong for more than 20 years because of its amazing food, awesome service, and popular catering. The restaurant's story began…
All Day
11:00 am - 8:40 pmFeatured Items
Opens 11:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Cheese Large 16"
$18.95
•92% (159)
#1 Most liked
Goodfella's Special Large 16"
$29.95
•90% (10)
Cheese Medium 14"
$15.95
•92% (68)
#3 Most liked
Build Your Own Wing
$16.95
•82% (56)
Penne A la Vodka with Chicken Pasta
$23.95
Spaghetti Carbonara Pasta
$19.95
•83% (12)
Reviews3k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
J
Jennifer B
9 contributionsLoved
• 10/1/26I got the Chicken Parmigiana Pasta , which came with a side of Italian Wedding Soup, and also ordered the Garlic Knots. I was blown away by the portion size of the chicken parm! Easily could've fed two adults, and possibly also a young child. You get six garlic knots that are each about the size of a dinner roll, which again is enough to feed 2-3 people. I compared prices of the chicken and garlic knots with a lot of places and thought this sounded like the best value after looking at reviews. I was not wrong! And the soup - best Wedding Soup I've ever had. I will absolutely be ordering here again.
A
Alex V
7 contributionsLiked
• 10/13/26 Best calamari i have ordered in awhile from other places they dont get it right, good fellas did. Cried alittle bit was that good. Salad on point, and meat balls great to good size for value.
C
Chelsea L
Emerging Expert • 6 contributionsLiked
• 1/6/26Cheese Calzone (Small) next to Cheese Calzone (Large) (with one bite taken out) Calzone was delicious and included ricotta which some places don't do anymore. You can see the difference in sizes the small is actually pretty big and the large is a decent size as well! We had 3 hungry adults and we ate on both for 2 days. Hot and fresh. Would order again!
J
Jake D
1 contributionsLoved
• 4/16/25Goodfella’s mozzarella sticks arrive piping hot, with a golden‑crisp crust giving way to molten, stretchy cheese that’s perfect with their bright, garlicky marinara. Their Tortellini Alfredo is equally impressive—plump, cheese‑filled pasta bathed in a silky Parmesan‑cream sauce, finished with cracked black pepper and parsley to cut the richness. Generous portions and authentic flavors make both irresistible.
M
Marissa R
12 contributionsLoved
• 9/5/25The is the ONLY place I will order a calzone from, not only is it always hot when I get it bc they make everything fresh but also it ALWAYS has perfect mixture of ricotta and mozzarella as sooo many places always put way too much of one or the other!!! Never had their pizza but their garlic knots are also amazing!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Foot Long Hot Subs
Foot Long Cold Subs
Garnished with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and house dressing.
Appetizers
Wings
Specialty Soups
Our chef's own recipe.
Salads
Pizza
Proudly Made with Grande Cheese the Finest Italian Cheese Money Can Buy. Sicilian 17" x 17". Large 16" 8 slices. Medium 14" 6 slices . Small 10" 4 slices