Support local businesses while treating your tastebuds! Try some of the top pizzas in Teaticket and find a new favorite. Papa Jake's Pizza remains one of the most popular in Teaticket. Give them a try…
super overpriced for a lg Pepperoni (Large) , which was paper thin and had barely any pepperoni on it and did not have extra cheese, which i payed for. the Greek Salad was the wrong mix, and i paid an extra $7.99 for steak and got 3 small tips on th salad. All in all, i feel like i just got bamboozled.
J
Jim K
2 contributions
Loved
• 2/19/22
• DoorDash order
The pizza is amazing. I am a fan of "chewy" cheese and crust and that's exactly what this was. The crust was crispy and the sauce was so flavorful. The Chicken Parm sandwich was soo good. The chicken had a great battered crust and was crispy. The sauce again was amazingly delicious. The roll, THE ROLL was so fresh and perfect. If you want great food come or order from this place. I will be back again and again.
T
Tim L
9 contributions
Liked
• 11/14/25
• DoorDash order
usually nothing but good experienceswith papa Jake's, they have in my opinionthe best jalapeño poppers in town, but today they were way overcooked, and myroast beef sandwhich looked raw. probably just a one time thing tho I'm sure
E
Eilean K
Local Expert • 34 contributions
Loved
• 3/19/25
• DoorDash order
Another great order! Pizzas ( Vegetarian (Large) and Pepperoni (Large)) arrived hot, fresh, extra saucy (as requested), and were loaded with toppings. Absolutely delicious!
A
Ari B
Emerging Expert • 44 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/20/25
• DoorDash order
Everything is just ok, the jalapeño poppers were a bit overcooked and the filling had a stale taste. Caesar salad tasted exactly like how you expect a Caesar salad to taste. The chicken tenders were good but didn't come with fries which is misleading considering the photo shows fries. Also the honey mustard is way too acidic; it made my nose run to the point I felt like I was eating wasabi.
