#39 Bill, Gary, and Beuford's Upper Yough Reuben was fantastic. Plenty of meat and cheese and flavorful. Bread was perfectly toasted and the portion was more than satisfactory. The garlic pickle was big,crisp and tasty. The chips were fine with good amount of salt.
A
Alecia W
4 contributions
Loved
• 2 days ago
• DoorDash order
That was the best Buckeye I've ever had that I didn't make!!! Impressed! Would've liked a bit more dressing on the #1 Katzinger's Reuben but overall was flavorful with lots of meat. The regular potato salad was creamy and the taters weren't mushy. Solid side choice! Didn't care for the liver but I think that's just a personal choice. I'll def order again. Thanks!
W
William C
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/27/26
• DoorDash order
The #17 Steve's Cross Currents was the tiniest version of this sandwich I've ever had yet the price is the same or more. The taste was decent, the Macaroni Salad was unique and taste decent more creamy than tangy. While the food was fine, I'm quite disappointed in the value versus similar delis I've been to in Michigan and Pennsylvania
M
Monica B
Local Expert • 54 contributions
Loved
• 5/30/25
• DoorDash order
The care and passion and dedication to excellence in a simple sandwich order tells you a lot about a business, and by that scale Katzinger's is the best of all Delis in central Ohio by a mile. Finding out that the Dublin location is (barely) in Doordash range will be transformational for me (and punishing for my wallet) going forward.
Macaroni Salad - generous portion, tastes like they made it fresh this morning, a cool and cozy blanket for the soul on a rainy spring day. Fresh dill and a perfect consistency make all the difference.
#39 Bill, Gary, and Beuford's Upper Yough Reuben - normally I'm not a fan of tee-hee variations on the classic Reuben but this one already came highly recommended and wow, those reviewers were on to something. The not-deli size was still generous but not overwhelming, and overstuffed on a smaller sliced loaf than the deli size, with meat and kraut falling out.
If even the pickles and sandwich crust are truly noteworthy - you can be sure the actual sandwich and sides are simply out of this world.
J
Jacob B
Emerging Expert • 40 contributions
Loved
• 10/3/25
• DoorDash order
Outstanding sandwich, a perfect amount of meat, plus the followed my instructions well, and it tasted fresh. I would order it again!
