Within the Cosimo family, gathering everyone around the table is a long-standing ritual. Our founder, Cosimo DiBrizzi, enjoyed nothing more than making dinner and sharing it with friends and family. W…
This was sooo good best italian ive had in a while. i asked for the Tomato Bruschetta to come deconstructed so it wouldnt get soggy and it was DELICIOUS when i put it together!
K
Katherine S
Emerging Expert • 27 contributions
Loved
• 9/17/25
• DoorDash order
You can never go wrong with Cosimos. Always absolutely phenomenal. I ordered the Fried Calamari it's crunchiness and so savory. They give you a good portion for the price. I would definitely order again. I asked for a side of lemons and they were nice enough to accommodate. Great place!
E
Erinne C
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Liked
• 1/1/25
• DoorDash order
the pastas were all incredible (Rigatoni Alla Buttera , Spicy Chicken Fusilli , Boscaiola - requested farfalle and it was honored. we did not care for the pizza - Spicy Fennel Sausage . also wish they would give more bread; with 3 people having pasta, we had to fight over it. really great pasta though.
E
Eric S
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/20/25
• DoorDash order
Don't waste your money on dessert. Ten dollars for the smallest slice of carrot cake I have ever seen. It was cut so thin it looked like a crumbeld mess. Embarrassing.
A
Amanda P
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/31/26
• DoorDash order
Ordred Parmigiana Classico and they charged an extra $6 to swap out pomodoro sauce and both the pasta and eggplant I ordered was extremely dry and bland. Definitely not wort the almost $30 after the upcharge. I've ordered this exact meal fom the Middletown and Newburgh locations and have never had an issue or upcharge.
