https://a816-health.nyc.gov/ABCEatsRestaurants/#!/Search
Magnolia is the bakery that put cupcakes on the map, but truth be told, this beloved bake shop is worth every bit of hype it’s ever received.…
The Classic Banana Pudding was the star of the order for me. Creamy, flavorful, and not too sweet. The Fully Loaded Icebox Bar was really good too. Would order both again. Not too sweet, just perfect. Portion could be a bit bigger for the Fully Loaded Icebox Bar, nevertheless, I would try it again.
J
Jessica M
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 6/10/25
• Commande DoorDash
Chocolate Cake Slice w/ Chocolate Buttercream. The best chocolate cake ever, and it's a big slice every time, taste super fresh 10/10. It's one of my favorites on the menu. Plus, the cupcakes, cookies too many to type out any buttercream dessert. it's just so good. I definitely recommend Chocolate Cake Slice w/ Chocolate Buttercream the best, mmmmhh, just delicious.
S
Sierra C
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/17/22
• Commande DoorDash
I got the brownie and red velvet cake. The brownie was good, a little dry. The red velvet cake is light. It's a really big slice so you get your money's worth in size. It's kinda dry, and the frosting is like mildly sweet air. If you like buttercream (I think that's what it is idk), you'll probably like this cake. I didnt because I was expecting cream cheese frosting.
E
Elena M
10 contributions
Loved
• 7/20/24
• Commande DoorDash
I'm super pregnant and I was cracing fresh baked goods in the middle of the night... I love Magnolia and they are absolutely not over-rated by any means. The Chocolate Cake Slice w/ Chocolate Buttercream was sooo moist and not too rich it was just right. The Cold Brew Banana Pudding Large was serving banana tiramisu realness - It's a must try.
L
L B
Local Expert • 106 contributions
Loved
• 5/13/24
• Commande DoorDash
RICH!! Only ate 25% of each cake hits like a brick. Classic Banana Pudding Large is whipped light & decadent sweet. I got a blue Vanilla Cake Slice w/ Vanilla Buttercream instead of the white looks like spirulina shade not neon blue to my relief. Very Sweet. frosting. Was a bit dry but went well with some of the pudding. Can taste the butter but not off putting like the Buttercream cakes at Whole Foods, which tastes like pure butter. Since I taste butter (not used to the real thing) could only finish almost half of the half lol. Carrot Cake Slice was moist, perfect sweet actually. All three sweetness linger in the throat, need some water. My mother loved the Banana Pudding it really made her Mother's Day she was raving, "Wow mmm this us REALLY GOOD" lol She also asked for some water. Lol been wanting to try the pudding for a long time. Finally glad I had the opportunity! The bag was stapled shut, thanks! Sorry forgot no pics, was digging in : D
