The very best pizza in town in my opinion. Love that one can get white sauce or red sauce as one of my family members cannot eat tomato sauce. Their crust and cheese are perfection. I like being able to add premium toppings like ricotta cheese too. I would not order their sausage as a topping again just because it is a sliced, spicy, coin shaped sausage and I prefer a milder crumble type of sausage on pizza. All their toppings and ingredients taste fresh and top notch though. Also Dewey's is the most consistently good pizza in town to me. I wish it was available on DoorDash or for delivery more often.
A
Andy T
124 contributions
Liked
• 8/4/26
• DoorDash order
13" Peach Street is an interesting seasonal pizza. I got it without onions, everything else went together surprisingly well. Not a pizza for when one is super hungry though as it at really light. I feel like it needs something else like the addition of feta, blue cheese, or ricotta. The peaches were good though. No taste of wine on them at all and they weren't soggy, just light refreshing peaches. Also got a sausage pizza and I have to remember I do not like the sausage at Dewey's. It is sausage slices, not crumbles. The sausage is sliced like the size of quarters and just too spicy for me.
A
Andy T
124 contributions
Loved
• 10/24/25
• DoorDash order
17" Smashing Pumpkin pizza is the very best pizza and I so wish they had it all year long or at least all fall. I get it without shallots but everything else about it is so delicious to me. I crave it year round. The crust is so fresh and the best of any pizza place in town in my opinion. The pumpkin base is mixed with ricotta and spread very thin (I wish I could get a little more on it) but it goes so well with the sausage crumbles and cheese on top and toasted mini pumpkin seeds. It is isn't like pumpkin pie at all. If you ever had a pumpkin ravioli and liked it you would like this. It is pumpkin in the savory direction and oh my goodness I dream about this pizza and check the app every day in October to see when it is available. It was only offered started this week and get it ASAP before it is gone for another year! Dewey's really should have it on the menu longer each year because to me it is the very best seasonal pizza they make.
K
Kristen M
1 contributions
Liked
• 2/23/26
• DoorDash order
Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and Caesar salad, it's usually really great. Lots of food, very fresh. However it was way too salty last night. I am not sure what happened, it's never tasted like that before. I think it was mostly the red sauce in the pizza but the Caesar dressing and ranch dipping was also really salty.
A
Allen S
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/1/25
• DoorDash order
The salads had very little cheese, literally 2-3 little chunks and very few berrys. Worst I've ever received from Dewey's.
