EAT HERE NOW. After leaving the East Coast, the one thing I've missed is the corner bodega delis of Brooklyn, where I routinely found the best sandwiches of all time. Until I met Mr Pickles!! I'll drive across town to get it so I'm over the moon to find it on DoorDash! Say Cheese is my go-to and it never fails to thrill me. The better half get the Big Jake again and again... to the same happy result. Vote Mr Pickles!
J
Joan H
1 contributions
Loved
• 11/5/25
• DoorDash order
The sandwiches are always so fresh. I've never had any issues with mistakes on my sandwiches. They are perfect every time. I definitely order again and again and again. I also love the fact that there are different sizes of sandwiches that you can order depending on what you're in the mood for.
G
Gale M
15 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/23/23
• DoorDash order
My supposed Chef Salad did not come with any of the meats nor cheeses so I paid almost $20 for lettuce and super watered down ranch dressing And the 1/2 ham sandwich only had half a slice of thin ham and all other sandwich making were very skimpy. I will never purchase from this place again.
P
Patty V
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/29/23
• DoorDash order
I declined the roasted pepper so I thought they would load up on the other items but the lettuce, tomatoe and onions were measly. Basically I paid $15.99 for a small tomatoe slice, could barely see the onion and lettuce was ver minimal. This was a vegan sandwich. The Dutch crunch roll was excellent. This restaurant really made a profit from my order.
R
Rudy R
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/8/25
• DoorDash order
We, historically, ordered from Mr. Pickle and have enjoyed their sandwiches. The Reuben has a tendon running through the whole sandwich, most of which had to be thrown out. The Mr. Pickle had had hardly any chicken and was there was overcooked, missing mayo, mustard and garlic sauce. Even the PB&J was awful, hardly any PB or J!! I wont be ordering from here anymore.
