Papa Johns is one of the few local places where if you order extra cheese you know you really get extra cheese. They load it on and I love it. Keeps me coming back. Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza was great.
S
S S
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/23/25
• DoorDash order
Cheese sticks were rubbery and cold, and they had no flavor. Usually, they have garlic butter, and they taste good. These are just really bland for some reason. Also, I've never seen such a tiny side of marinara with an entire order of cheese sticks. This is 1/4 the size of what we normally receive from them.
S
Santosh K
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/2/25
• DoorDash order
Just had an amazing experience with Papa John’s! I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and another large half cheese, half veggie, and everything was spot-on. The pepperoni had a bold, savory flavor with crispy edges and the right amount of spice, while the cheese pizza was perfectly simple with rich, melty mozzarella. The veggie half was super fresh—loaded with crisp green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black olives that tasted like they were just chopped. The crust on all the slices was warm, soft on the inside, and had a nice golden edge crunch with that signature slight sweetness. Portions were generous—each slice was big and fully loaded, and the two pizzas were more than enough for our group. Everything arrived hot, fresh, and clearly made with care. I’d absolutely order again—this combo hit every craving and made for a great shared meal. Papa John’s really delivered both in flavor and quality!
A
Andy S
Local Expert • 50 contributions
Liked
• 1/22/26
• DoorDash order
I've already reviewed the other items here and they all get a thumbs up and a positive review every time I go. They have a new dessert item, which is the. Blondie butterscotch brownie or something. I don't have the name right but it's very good. I think I'm now addicted to these little things and they are delicious! I think it's called a maple brownie. The reason I can't give the exact name is because when I'm on this review screen, I'm locked in here and can't get out to look at anything else on the app. That's something that maybe DoorDash could fix a little bit with their software. Once again, a solid A+ to Papa Johns. And I think it's awesome that they're open nightly seven nights a week until 3 AM. Love this place! 
J
Jon P
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/2/22
• DoorDash order
Pizza is meh. The wings, when I said "well done", came not even close and were soggy. I even put them in the crisper at home and that didn't crisp them up. Biggest thing is the pizza is meh. The price of the pizza is absolutely silly for the product.
