New York Pizzeria first opened its doors in 1984. The original founder, Bob Gillis, owns and operates New York Pizzeria, which is run by family and friends. Come experience the best pizza and service …
Full Menu
10:30 am - 9:05 pm
Featured Items
Opens 10:30 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Cheese Pizza Hand-Tossed with 1 Inch Crust (X-Large 16")
Our first time to order from this restaurant and we're glad we did. The pizza though may need more toast but, it taste good. The spaghetti was cooked well. Flavorful, not salty and so with the meatballs. Generous serving. We'll do it again.
C
Chrissy J
Local Expert • 45 contributions
Liked
• 10/12/25
• DoorDash order
The Cheese Pizza Hand-Tossed with 1 Inch Crust (Large 14") was delicious as always. The tomatoes and garlic were very fresh. The Spaghetti was a good portion and always saucy just the way the kids like. I would order again however my salad was missing from the order this time.
D
Devin M
3 contributions
Liked
• 12/16/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza was a five out of 10. I'm comparing this to genuine New York Pizza. If this was just pizza in general, then I would rate it a 7.5. However, the pizza box did not have a sticker seal when it was delivered and the ranch was one dollar even though it was very small. For those small sizes it should be about $.25 per side of ranch. And the image of the Pepsi was the 20 ounce bottle so I got two of them, but then I got the 2 L bottles instead. If you could fix the image that would be great. I didn't get napkins or utensils like I asked for so that was an inconvenience as well. Overall Rating 3/10
C
Chrissy J
Local Expert • 45 contributions
Loved
• 2/23/26
• DoorDash order
Great food. Spaghetti was delicious. Pizza was hot and fresh. Good size portion for 2 to 3 people. My go to order!
J
Jairis D
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/31/24
• DoorDash order
The crust is sprinkled with oregano, always crispy and delicious. Sauce and cheese is absolutely to die for.
I'm originally from NY and I've been on the search for great pizza. The first time I had it, I actually cried, it's been seven years since I've had good NY pizza. I had the opportunity to speak to the owner, whose family hails from NY. He has a ton of NY memorabilia that makes it genuie and a great place to visit in person as well.
